- This topic is empty.
-
AuthorPosts
-
April 12, 2009 at 7:14 pm #203953
Anonymous
GuestI apologize in advance for how long this post is, but I promise this is a sincere cry for help. I stopped going to Church last October. My reasons for doing this mirror the common themes on this forum. I am not going to go into them because right now those reasons aren’t as imperative.
The enabler of me actually leaving was my wife and I separated. When we separated she went to live several states away with our three children to be near her family. She was a homemaker so she needed the support of her family both emotionally and financially. I supported her decision to do this, knowing she wouldn’t be happy staying in my home state without a support system.
Being on my own took away the drive I had to attend Church for the children. When my wife left I immediately stopped going. I went into a dark depression and began self-medicated myself using illegal drugs – mostly marijuana. As I fell deeper into depression I threw away the moral code. I talked myself into thinking that because the Church wasn’t true, who is to say fidelity, taking care of our bodies, etc. was true? This led me to much more heinous acts including prostitution.
In March, I became suicidal. I would go to work, come home to smoke marijuana, and lay in my bed all day. Thanks to the help of a co-worker who recognized that something was wrong I admitted myself to a psychiatric hospital to get treatment. I have had depression and ADD since I was a youth. The psychiatrists changed my medication, switching me to a different antidepressant and giving me stronger medication for the ADD. This seemed to awaken my from a deep sleep and I began to think clearly again. I also received behavioral therapy which has helped me tremendously.
During my treatment I kept feeling a hole in my Spirit. I had the right medication, great therapy but what about all of the mistakes I made in the months before? And I couldn’t help but wonder if my depression had been the true reason behind my wife and I separating. And if it was, because of what I had done it would be near impossible to expect her to want to work on our marriage.
I realized that I needed to follow the repentance process to fill that void. I emailed my Bishop confessing everything I had done. We had a meeting and he is in the process of scheduling a meeting with the stake president because of the seriousness of my mistakes. Starting this process has made me feel great.
But because I know in my heart I do not believe in some of the fundamental doctrines of the Church – serious ones such as it being the one true Church, its teachings of the Savior (I do not believe in the traditional Atonement) and its emphasis on Priesthood Authority (the God franchise) – I am now feeling my actions are dishonest. My supportive parents advise me to talk through these issues with the Bishop, but they don’t understand that these aren’t just doubts; I have come to the conclusion that they simply don’t work for me. To force myself to believe them would have an even more negative impact on my soul.
I am unsure and confused how to go through the repentance process. I know that excommunication or disfellowship are likely consequences. I am willing to do what is required to overcome these consequences. But it is hard not to feel dishonest about it.
I have been a fan of John Dehlin ever since I returned from my mission in 2004. I went to Mormon Stories and found this forum. I am hoping that I have found a support system that can help me through this time in my life.
April 12, 2009 at 11:00 pm #216505Anonymous
GuestFirst, welcome to this forum. I sincerely hope it helps. Next, a few thoughts – just my initial impressions and feelings as I read:
1) Depression and ADD (and other “disabilities”) have been under-addressed, imo, in the construction and discussion of repentance.
I personally think MANY things done “under the influence” of such issues fall more under the umbrella of “transgression” than “sin”– which leads me to how I differentiate two different types of repentance: a) “reactive repentance” – the classic case of responding to a sin already committed and “going through the steps of repentance” made famous by Pres. Kimball. This is necessary when sins are particularly serious (or have become habitualized) and when they need to be confessed – like your illegal drug use and prostitution, for example.
b) “proactive repentance” – the process of change and growth outlined in the Sermon on the Mount, where “change” is described NOT as the cutting out of bad but rather the acquisition of good. I believe this is MUCH more enabling and a better approach for the vast majority of “sins which so easily beset us.
I’ve written a lot about the general theme of an expanded view of repentance, so rather than try to write a novel here I am going to link to some posts that talk of these things more extensively. (Because of the way the urls get abbreviated in this forum, I am going to include the urls and the actual titles – so you can decide if you want to read them and in what order.)
From this forum:
1) Personal Focus (
) – This is about pursuing spiritual growth outside of “the Church” as an independent journey – and it deals with proactive repentance.http://forum.staylds.com/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=82 From my own blog:
1) A “Fresh View” of Repentance (
) – This outlines how I came to think of proactive repentance vs. reactive repentance.http://thingsofmysoul.blogspot.com/2008/01/rethinking-repentance.html 2) “More Thoughts on Repentance” (
) – This is exactly what the title suggests, something I wrote after writing “A Fresh View of Repentance”.http://thingsofmysoul.blogspot.com/2008/06/more-thoughts-on-repentance.html Finally, I am going to write a separate post about reactive and proactive repentance, adapted from a talk I gave a few months ago. It’s too long to include as a comment.
Again, welcome. I hope you find a measure of peace here among us and discover a way to rebuild a life that will bring you joy.
April 13, 2009 at 2:09 pm #216506Anonymous
GuestHey Lonleytraveler, I am so sorry to hear about the rough road you traveled recently. I am glad you feel like you are getting your head clear. You seem to be thinking actively about your direction, and about healing. Hang in there! It sounds like you have people there who care and are working with you, like your Bishop. This is just my opinion from observations, but I don’t know if those ecclesiastical authorities are the right people to share your doubts with. It *REALLY* strongly depends on the person, and not their calling or position. They might be. You are the best judge of that, since you know them better. I don’t know if I would recommend mixing your traditional Church repentence process with your exploration of resolving doubts at the same time. I say work on one thing at a time. Getting through the outward Church process sounds like the first thing to resolve. Can you have hope or wish some of these things are true? You can go on that. You could also just leave it all on the shelf for a little while longer and address it when you get the first part done.
I get the impression that going through the repentence process at Church will be cleansing and helpful to you, regardless of your belief in absolute Truth or priesthood authority. You’ve done some serious things that you regret. It has caused real world problems for you. Look at the repentence process as a ritual of cleansing perhaps. Of course you still have to find ways to forgive yourself. I know I am my own worst judge. Going through the Church also has a practical benefit. Your wife may be more willing to work with you, and come to a place of forgiveness and compassion, if she is a more orthodox LDS member. It might give her more faith in your changes if she sees the outward manifestations. I don’t mean this in a cynical, manipulative way. I hope you really are seeking change and resolution. I feel that from you. It sounds like you would like to try and bring your family back together. That is good, especially if you are getting help for your problems.
Back to your doubts. It’s ok. You are not alone. It is ok to have hope in things being true, or to see them in different ways. It’s ok to take what you find is good, to value and enjoy it, and to leave other things behind. We’re here to talk about that with each other. This is a safe place to tell your story, listen to what others have found, and find a new path of faith (whatever that may be) within the LDS Church.
April 14, 2009 at 4:01 am #216507Anonymous
GuestThank you both for you help. I agree that right now I need to just focus on dedicating myself to the repentance process. I feel that I can be honest with my priesthood leaders and say I have a very weak testimony – leaving it at that.
What has brought me a lot of comfort is this heading in the “How to Stay in the LDS Church After a Major Challenge to Your Faith” essay –
Faith (or hope) is an amazingly low bar. “Knowledge” and “true” are often unrealistic ones.I want to have faith that if I approach the repentance process with honesty I can be healed from my guilt. I am also encouraged that it may provide some relief to my wife, whether she decides to work on it or not. It just feels like the right thing to do.
I love your blog, Ray, and feel that you have captured the essence of repentance that I agree with. Instead of just focusing on making sure I abstain from those illegal activities I participated in, I am also going to incorporate more “good” in my life.
April 14, 2009 at 4:09 am #216508Anonymous
GuestQuote:I want to have faith that if I approach the repentance process with honesty I can be healed from my guilt.
Quote:Faith (or hope) is an amazingly low bar. “Knowledge” and “true” are often unrealistic ones.
lonelytraveler, Thank you for your kind words. Based on the two quotes above, you might want to read the following three posts, as well:
“Embracing Grace” (
)http://thingsofmysoul.blogspot.com/2007/11/embracing-grace.html “Cast Thy Burden Upon the Lord” (
)http://thingsofmysoul.blogspot.com/2008/10/cast-thy-burden-at-his-feet.html “Faith, Doubt and Enduring Uncertainty” (
)http://thingsofmysoul.blogspot.com/2009/04/faith-doubt-and-enduring-uncertainty.html April 14, 2009 at 5:36 am #216509Anonymous
GuestLonelyTraveler, Welcome to our forums. I am impressed by the earnest and sincere way you are approaching your turnabout and growth. Keep believing and you will do just fine. There are some concepts that you have been seeing more clearly about the church, and now you add the more important way of seeing that involves your actions. It can all add up to growth as long as you keep an earnest, reverent, manner of seeking.
I’m very sorry that bitterness and anger got a foothold in you for a time (if I understand correctly), and I feel with Ray that your cross must have been very heavy. I agree deeply with his letter b) of repentance. The turnaround you have made already is impressive. There is no need to put a negative spin on the positive changes in your perspective regarding gospel and church. Rather than thinking or describing your testimony as being “weak”, present it as “new”, “astonishing”, and “more fulfilling” if that’s what it seems to you. Rejoice in the good and hold firmly to it.
You never will undo the positive learning you have experienced about Truth uniqueness, Atonement, and Priesthood. But with your new (and future!) perspectives, our hope here is that the church can have new meaning for you, and you for it.
I’m rooting for you.
April 14, 2009 at 5:48 pm #216510Anonymous
GuestLonelytraveler. Welcome, friend. I struggle with depression and have had many struggles as you have had. I cannot say that I have had many of the experiences that you have had, but I can say that depression has made it impossible at times to find any positive feeling at all, whether spiritual or emotional.
I will say more later, but for now welcome and thank you for sharing your story. Your story is real, your feelings are real, and the love of Christ is real. He loves you and he loves me, even if we can’t feel it all the time.
April 14, 2009 at 5:53 pm #216511Anonymous
GuestI guess I have to say one more thing about repentance. I don’t think you need to worry about following any checklist to try and purge pot from your life. I think you probably should figure out how to make sure it doesn’t come back, but you’ve obviously got a heart of gold. Do whatever you can to cope with your depression and feel something good. Don’t just do good things, actively seek good feelings. Those good feelings will motivate you to find your own authentic version of repentance to make you right with the Lord. Those good feelings ARE authentic repentance. People who feel ennobled and kind make mistakes, but they’ll always be improving and moving closer to God. I can testify that going to therapy and taking medication was one of the hardest steps I’ve ever taken. I’ll probably be on antidepressants for my whole life. But it was all worth it when I started, ever so rarely, to have real emotions connected to real events. When that happens, you can feel good when you love somebody, and that’s going to get you further than any talk with your bishop. April 14, 2009 at 7:35 pm #216512Anonymous
Guestlonely traveler – welcome to the site. Thanks for sharing your story. My heart goes out to you. I know that medication for illness can radically change one’s perspective. I’m glad you are getting the treatment you need. I agree with Valoel’s advice to keep your process with ecclesiastical leaders separate from your doubts. Quote:But because I know in my heart I do not believe in some of the fundamental doctrines of the Church – serious ones such as it being the one true Church, its teachings of the Savior (I do not believe in the traditional Atonement) and its emphasis on Priesthood Authority (the God franchise)
I will just say (somewhat in jest), if you don’t like the doctrines, just stick around – they often change! After all, “doctrines” are the teachings that are being emphasized and how they are being interpreted currently. I sometimes wonder if we are born at a specific time because we couldn’t have dealt with the “doctrines” of another time. For example, consider the first one you listed above:
“one true church”– this could mean we are the only ones with truth (others are deceived), we have all the truth (which is obviously not correct), or we have the most truth (mixed with some error – this is obviously too subjective to judge), we have the smallest errors or the biggest truths (try to measure those across religions), or we encompass the correct beliefs of all the churches and that exist outside churches (we add truth and subtract error on an ongoing basis – e.g. we have no fixed canon), or we have access to all truth through the holy ghost and belief in personal ongoing revelation (yet we may misunderstand truth through our human error – and this doesn’t preclude others from having inspiration). You can find different quotes from church leaders with different definitions of this one. April 14, 2009 at 10:05 pm #216513Anonymous
GuestThank you all for your kind words. You have given me strength. April 19, 2009 at 2:25 am #216514Anonymous
GuestI wanted to give everyone an update. Unfortunately, the medications my psychiatrist had prescribed backfired and sent me into a manic state. Because of this, he is 99.9% sure I am bipolar and I have started taking Lithium.
I went to see the Stake President last week and I could not ask for more compassion. He told me he wanted me to quit worrying about Church and focus on my mental health. He said the Church will continue to be here to help, but he doesn’t want me worrying about my worthiness until I am stabilized. I thought this was a very charitable approach from this priesthood leader. He even shared a personal story of a friend that had struggled with mental illness, and confirmed that you can overcome it.
I thought it would be good to post a positive note on a priesthood leader approaching mental illness with compassion and love.
April 19, 2009 at 2:51 am #216515Anonymous
GuestThank God for good, humble men of God. I couldn’t have said it any better if I had a month to prepare. I teared up a bit reading your update. Thank you for writing it and letting us know.
April 19, 2009 at 5:17 am #216516Anonymous
GuestThank you, Lonelytraveler, for updating, sharing, and inspiring. April 22, 2009 at 2:17 am #216517Anonymous
GuestYes. Thank you to you for sharing and to your leader for caring. Please keep us updated and hang in there. April 27, 2009 at 10:43 pm #216518Anonymous
GuestLonelytraveler, I’m sorry to hear about your struggle. I had a brother-in-law with bipolar and it was very difficult for him. Sometimes others around you cannot understand what is going on. I hope you can find something that will work for you. -
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.