Home Page › Forums › General Discussion › Truth. Error. Opinion. Revelation.
- This topic is empty.
-
AuthorPosts
-
July 30, 2009 at 4:07 pm #204191
Anonymous
GuestOne of my favorite scripture ideas comes from Jacob where he talks about how the spirit teaches things as “they really are” and as they “really will be”. And I am fairly sure that how things really are is different from what mormon culture ( at any time in history) says it is. What if the truth isn’t what I want it to be? What if the truth doesn’t fall into my comfort zone or frame of reference? Does that mean that I am not reading the spirit right or that something inside of me is warning me?
I know I have to humble myself to God and perhaps do things I don’t agree with. But I also see God teaching me to trust my instincts and my inner voice. Sometimes I don’t feel the Spirit confirm or guide, other times I do.
Sometimes I worry that because I was born and raised in the church and in a dominant LDS environment that this more than anything has shaped my testimony. I know that can’t all be true because I know God has taught me things.
I guess I just want to know that I am seeing things (history, doctrine, temporal state) as they really are and as they really will be, because anything less is just a waste. And I guess at the end of the day I do believe in personal revelation and faith and all the things that open ones spiritual eyes to truth.
I not saying this very well.
July 30, 2009 at 4:58 pm #220385Anonymous
GuestPoppyseed wrote:One of my favorite scripture ideas comes from Jacob where he talks about how the spirit teaches things as “they really are” and as they “really will be”. And I am fairly sure that how things really are is different from what mormon culture ( at any time in history) says it is.
D&C 76: 94
94 They who dwell in his presence are the church of the Firstborn; and they
see as they are seen, and know as they are known, having received of his fulness and of his grace; I agree. I am not there, yet the spirit leads me and brings me closer, as I give heed.
Poppyseed wrote:What if the truth isn’t what I want it to be? What if the truth doesn’t fall into my comfort zone or frame of reference? Does that mean that I am not reading the spirit right or that something inside of me is warning me?
I said in another thread, that truth is a terrible master. Not because it is ‘bad’, but because it is painful. It is painful because it is a two-edged sword, cutting away from us (other things/people) and towards us (ourselves). You cannot wield it without facing that reality. Justice is an aspect of truth. Both are very limiting, very strict. You want to hold others to that standard? Then you also must be judged by that standard. Thus, it is terrible.
Yet, it is an aspect or attribute of godliness. It is on one end of a spectrum, the opposite end being Mercy, an equal aspect of godliness. Steadfast Love. In the hebrew, the word for judgement is Geburah; the word for Steadfast Love is Chesed. They two are balanced and thus made ‘right’ by Tipareth in hebrew, “Beauty” in english. Or, metaphorically, the Sun. Even, the Son. Yes, Jews know about the Son, and his role in atonement. The ones that study their religion, anyway.
Poppyseed wrote:I know I have to humble myself to God and perhaps do things I don’t agree with. But I also see God teaching me to trust my instincts and my inner voice. Sometimes I don’t feel the Spirit confirm or guide, other times I do.
Same here. I was led by the spirit, once, to a very scary place after studying D&C 132. I rejected the teaching of the Spirit, and was left alone for years thereafter, for by my choice I declared that I was not ready for that light in my life. The topic was not polygamy, yet was contained in that section. Seek and ye shall find sounds pretty harmless, but it is the way to truth, and that is far from harmless for those not prepared for it. In Jewish mysticsm, they do not approach Truth or Da’at (knowledge itself) directly. They know the price. Better to live as we believe we should, and let truth distill upon us at its own pace.
Poppyseed wrote:Sometimes I worry that because I was born and raised in the church and in a dominant LDS environment that this more than anything has shaped my testimony. I know that can’t all be true because I know God has taught me things.
Me too.
Poppyseed wrote:I guess I just want to know that I am seeing things (history, doctrine, temporal state) as they really are and as they really will be, because anything less is just a waste. And I guess at the end of the day I do believe in personal revelation and faith and all the things that open ones spiritual eyes to truth.
I disagree that it is a waste. That is like saying that a life not lived perfectly is a waste. It serves a purpose. We grow and learn. We cannot be what we are not, and cannot yet endure what we shall be. Hope is the key; Hope and patience.
Poppyseed wrote:I not saying this very well.
It is a miracle when we speak truth and do it well. I enjoy your posts, Poppyseed.HiJolly
July 30, 2009 at 7:20 pm #220386Anonymous
GuestWonderful thread. HiJolly wrote:It is painful because it is a two-edged sword, cutting away from us (other things/people) and towards us (ourselves). You cannot wield it without facing that reality. Justice is an aspect of truth. Both are very limiting, very strict. You want to hold others to that standard? Then you also must be judged by that standard. Thus, it is terrible.
Thanks for sharing this insight. Yeowwww! I have been experiencing this anew lately. It truly is as you described, glory be to the Father.
August 10, 2009 at 12:43 am #220387Anonymous
GuestQuote:by Poppyseed » 30 Jul 2009, 10:07
One of my favorite scripture ideas comes from Jacob where he talks about how the spirit teaches things as “they really are” and as they “really will be”. And I am fairly sure that how things really are is different from what mormon culture ( at any time in history) says it is.
Poppyseed, I am absolutely charmed by the idea of someone quoting mormon scripture in the first sentence, and in the second, suggesting the culture that produced the book you quoted has strayed apart from the very book you quote.
August 10, 2009 at 1:05 am #220388Anonymous
GuestI agree, a wonderful thread. There are some profound insights here. It all makes me feel that I know how little I really know.
August 10, 2009 at 1:12 am #220389Anonymous
Guestjeriboy wrote:by Poppyseed » 30 Jul 2009, 10:07
One of my favorite scripture ideas comes from Jacob where he talks about how the spirit teaches things as “they really are” and as they “really will be”. And I am fairly sure that how things really are is different from what mormon culture ( at any time in history) says it is.
Poppyseed, I am absolutely charmed by the idea of someone quoting mormon scripture in the first sentence, and in the second, suggesting the culture that produced the book you quoted has strayed apart from the very book you quote.
Well, in PS’ defense, he says “mormon culture” suggesting the culture that has come asa resultof said book, not necessarily the same culture that produced the book. Surely today we aren’t using peepstones to get revelation, find buried treasure etc. all of which helped produce the BoM. Even within 10 years after the BoM came forth JS was reducing use of his peepstone and other superstitious roots. August 10, 2009 at 2:53 am #220390Anonymous
Guestjeriboy wrote:Quote:by Poppyseed » 30 Jul 2009, 10:07
One of my favorite scripture ideas comes from Jacob where he talks about how the spirit teaches things as “they really are” and as they “really will be”. And I am fairly sure that how things really are is different from what mormon culture ( at any time in history) says it is.
Poppyseed, I am absolutely charmed by the idea of someone quoting mormon scripture in the first sentence, and in the second, suggesting the culture that produced the book you quoted has strayed apart from the very book you quote.
Well, I am all fine with this! I have many contradictions in my thinking right now. I am absolutely ok with that and even ok with you pointing it out. I wouldn’t doubt I was alone in that circumstance, especially here on this site.
But having said that, don’t you think that most of our conversations here (not to mention the objectives of religion and science) are to reveal things as they really are and as they really will be? Forget where I am getting the quote. I think the idea is the foundation of many of the arguments on this site. And I think I started this thread because I think sometimes we get in our own way with our attempts to discern truth.
Oh…and btw I am a girlie kind.
August 10, 2009 at 3:50 am #220391Anonymous
GuestQuote:Poppyseed said….Oh…and btw I am a girlie kind.
Thank you for making me laugh in a very nice way. I enjoy yours and everyone’s point of view on these threads. They are forcing me to think deeper, grow larger, choose words more carefully, and to like the personalitys that peek through the words, thank you.
August 10, 2009 at 5:24 am #220392Anonymous
GuestPoppyseed wrote:Oh…and btw I am a girlie kind.

Dang it!! I’m sorry about that. Somewhere in the back of my mind I knew that, I just forgot temporarily.August 10, 2009 at 10:16 am #220393Anonymous
GuestDear Poppyseed, I loved your post. I truly believe the scripture that we should “prove all things” and “hold fast that which is good”.
We each have many things to learn, but UNLEARNING things is also part of the process. We have to be willing to “unlearn”, forget, let go of, or abandon false notions, errors and bad habits that inevitably enter our world. I was a science major and false “facts” can even be found in science textbooks. Knowledge must be sorted, shifted, discarded, saved, refined and perfected – constantly.
Galileo Galilei was excommunicated by the Catholic Church for teaching that the earth revolved around the sun. His science “crossed the line” and his writings appeared to insult the intelligence of the Pope. As we gain more knowledge, we will constantly be confronted with new truth. Some of our old truth will be proved false and will have to be discarded. This is part of proving and testing knowledge.
The glory of God is intelligence and this is how we acquire it.
August 11, 2009 at 5:45 pm #220394Anonymous
GuestThere are some really good things posted in the above postings…and I really like the subject of truth and the pursuit of truth. (thanks for starting the thread, dear miss poppyseed )
I was really impressed with the things HiJolly said, especially this quote:
HiJolly wrote:Better to live as we believe we should, and let truth distill upon us at its own pace.
Wise words, zenmaster HiJolly!I also like Wallace’s words:
MWallace57 wrote:We each have many things to learn, but UNLEARNING things is also part of the process. We have to be willing to “unlearn”, forget, let go of, or abandon false notions, errors and bad habits that inevitably enter our world. I was a science major and false “facts” can even be found in science textbooks. Knowledge must be sorted, shifted, discarded, saved, refined and perfected – constantly.
[snip]
As we gain more knowledge, we will constantly be confronted with new truth. Some of our old truth will be proved false and will have to be discarded. This is part of proving and testing knowledge.
Excellent, and I agree. I would just add my thoughts to clarify … I think the truth is constant and universal, but our understanding or our perception of it is limited to our capabilities. So while Galileo came across a new truth, the “old truth” didn’t change, the universe was still the way it was, it was just not understood by many people at that time, so the accepted truth was what changed, not the truth itself…which is what I believe you were also getting at, right?I find it comforting to believe that there is one universal truth [who God is, what our existence is on this earth, what will happen after this life, etc], and that the Spirit can speak that to us. However, I leave a large room for error on my ability to grasp “the truth” and understand it, so I go back to HiJolly’s zen teachings that it is better I live as I believe, and let that truth distill on me at its own pace.
August 11, 2009 at 5:49 pm #220395Anonymous
GuestDear Herber13, You are absolutely right. Universal Truth is CONSTANT, but our understanding of it grows and changes. The gospel truths do not change because they are eternal.
August 12, 2009 at 12:02 am #220396Anonymous
GuestPoppyseed wrote:I guess I just want to know that I am seeing things (history, doctrine, temporal state) as they really are and as they really will be, because anything less is just a waste. And I guess at the end of the day I do believe in personal revelation and faith and all the things that open ones spiritual eyes to truth.
I have a feeling that history, doctrine, our temporal state especially, even our “reality” is all an illusion, a distraction, and quite often both.
I also have a sneaking suspicion that our personal revelation guides us in the right way, even when we are wrong about our assumptions or conclusions. It’s hard, but trusting in the journey *IS* the all important “Faith” I think prophets talk about. At least those that really know.
It’s a somewhat radical idea within Mormon culture, but I think making mistakes and failure *IS* sometimes the actual experience some people need to progress. There’s nothing like falling flat on ones faith, in front of everyone, to arouse that oh-so important sense of humility

So what I am getting at is this: “Truth. Error. Opinion. Revelation.” It’s ok. We are going to have a little bit of all that as we head towards the measure of our creation.
August 12, 2009 at 12:29 am #220397Anonymous
GuestI love the concept here, and the title speaks volumes. I think the key to the phrase, “things as they really are and as they really will be” is what kind of truth are we talking about and what kinds of things? The phrase to me refers to a worldview – seeing the world and ourselves and other people for what they/we really are. Maybe it has to do with spiritual truth or self-knowledge or psychology or science, but it could mean lots of things. Plus, it’s just one guy’s view, right? Nephi’s or Joseph Smith’s, however you look at it. Mormon culture’s worldview, BTW, is also fragmented and incomplete. No one claims to understand it all, and if they do they are full of it! Also, part of enlightenment is to question your assumptions about your worldview and to live in the moment. To me, that’s still consistent with that statement, but about 90% or more of human beings go through life without ever questioning the assumptions associated with their worldview.
August 13, 2009 at 7:59 pm #220398Anonymous
GuestQuote:So what I am getting at is this: “Truth. Error. Opinion. Revelation.” It’s ok. We are going to have a little bit of all that as we head towards the measure of our creation.
I like this. I like this a lot. Thank you. I hadn’t considered it when I first posted. But I think there is wisdom here.
Sometimes I think God looks back at us and says “what do you think?” and “Why don’t you try that for a while and then we’ll talk.” I think that God must want us to think for ourselves (not just follow Him) as we evaluate scripture and revelation and life experience together. Or is thinking for ourselves part of following Him?
I wonder sometimes too about people with differing perspectives and wonder if that is part of the value God is putting into life experience as we rub shoulders with one another. I met an atheist once who really touched my heart and stretched my mind. I felt so grateful for my conversations with him and grateful for how I was changed thru the interaction. It felt like God kinda opened my mind to this persons worth just the way he was. Maybe God allows this variety so that we do stretch. Maybe fulfilling the measure of our creation means that we flower in these differences for a while before conversion comes. I don’t know exactly how to square that with the whole one faith one baptism perspective. But maybe it is ok because this earth isn’t the place where everything will be resolved. Perhaps their are seasons and God lets those seasons play out. And maybe that is good.
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.