Home Page › Forums › General Discussion › RE: Faith, Poltitics, Socialism-Lost Faith.
- This topic is empty.
-
AuthorPosts
-
November 3, 2012 at 11:18 pm #207166
Anonymous
GuestI’m having a really big issue right now. We don’t even have a ward employment specialist in the ward. I have been unemployed for 16 months. Never has anyone in the Church approached me about my situation, they just ask: have you found a job yet? I had one Bishop say it is not the Church’s job to help you get a job, it is a struggle you must do alone, like Jesus in Gethsemane. I have gone to LDS employment services and they help a bit and at least give me a semblance of hope. NOW I find myself losing faith in Godand I am told that I need to place my faith in Man: either Barak Obama or Mitt Romney. Which president is going to make the economic environment better so I can get back on my feet again? Neither person will help the poor. Jesus said that the poor will always be with us. One is more keen on redistribution (Barak Obama), but that doesn’t cure my depression from not having a job. So Obviously Obama is out. I don’t care about redistribution of wealth. I want a job so maybe one day I can have wealth to spread around to those I would bless. I’m approaching middle age really fast, and I’m getting worried that I will just quit the faith and find whatever job I can and stick it out that way. I have had a job offer and then I called to follow up on the details and the rug was pulled out from under me and the people said that I was no longer needed, and that they made a mistake and reassured me that I had a great resume and they would call me in the future if they had a fit for me. This is a load of B.S. (I am almost ready to join the occupy movement.) I felt God’s hands, or so I thought in my mind leading me up to this point. Again, a TBM would say the other party had agency and they chose to not hire you after all. So, I wonder why the hell should I try, when no one gives a crap about human beings anymore. The doctrine of Nehor is prevails, “survival for the fittest. It’s even in the Church. Outdo your brother, step on the next person to get ahead. Every ward has the mansions on the hill, or on the other side of the tracks, and the lowly apartments and mediocre homes on the south side of the tracks, or in the valley below. Mormonism is a failure. Socialism wins. Ezra Taft Benson warned the Church, but even members are super greedy just like their fellow Americans. Glen Beck says that socialism prevails when Greed enters Capitalism. Once individuals become greedy, the focus of the whole point is gone. It no longer is win/win, it becomes lose-win. One person makes the profit while the others have to grovel for the crumbs below.
The Church doesn’t help me to find work. The Church only wants people with money coming in. I guess the 3,000 to 5,000 bucks I donated in tithing in past years doesn’t amount to crap. So, I guess members should just stop paying tithing. I don’t see blessings from it. I just see luck of the draw. Gordon B. Hinkcley conveniently died after his talk on 7 years of plenty followed by 7 lean years. He didn’t have to see people suffer. He will say he was a child of the depression, but he had it made once he went to work for the church after his mission, he couldn’t relate to the common man. I have more school than I need, and have to lie about my schooling sometimes so I can get a minimum wage job. I’m at the point where I will have to seek out friends and people I know and convince them why they should hire me; It’s who you know, not what you know-right?
I don’t understand why i have to put my faith in man, when God is the person we are supposed to put our faith in.I’m having a faith crisis right now. I told my wife last night that If I don’t get a job by June 2013, I will drive my car off a cliff. She thinks I’m crazy now, and wont talk to me. I go to therapy now, but it only helps me feel fine for about three days and then I’m back to facing my demons and the hosts of hell, I even hate my fellowman. Everyone with a job has become my enemy. But the TBM’s at Church will tell me: ‘have more faith’ B.S. I want to quip back, “go to hell. You cannot endure what I have.” I’m at the point where God doesn’t care if I’m employed. I should just stay on welfare and be depressed, and embrace Socialism.
November 4, 2012 at 12:08 am #261285Anonymous
GuestI don’t have time to respond fully right now, but I just want to remind everyone of the mission of this site and ask that this not turn into a discussion / debate about politics in any way. That’s not what we do here. Let’s try to talk about coping mechanisms, “solutions” to specific situations and issues relative to staying LDS.
Having said that, jamison, I really feel for you. I’ve been unemployed for varying lengths of time at three different points in my life. Unemployment sucks and can be extremely draining emotionally.
November 4, 2012 at 6:25 am #261286Anonymous
Guestjamison wrote:I had one Bishop say it is not the Church’s job to help you get a job, it is a struggle you must do alone, like Jesus in Gethsemane. I have gone to LDS employment services and they help a bit and at least give me a semblance of hope.
I can only begin to understand your pain and frustration. I went through a period of unemployment last year. Every Sunday for 8 months my Bishop asked me how work was going and every Sunday I had to explain to him that I was unemployed. I would of thought the lack of tithing coming from me would have helped him remember.
Anyway, for what it’s worth stay strong and I hope things work out.
November 4, 2012 at 3:16 pm #261287Anonymous
GuestI have often thought that the true church would have somehow figured out how to manage the temporal affairs of its members by now. It would have instituted job training, built industry to employ its many members, and become a business yes but one that caters to the needs of its members by providing quality employment. This would be the true church to me. Unfortunately we do not have that. Yes we have a business entity as a church but the things it finds important are really just smoke and mirrors. The church and members continually talk about nuance and “spiritual” things as though they really have any understanding at all. That somehow if they tweak this doctrine or that the world will make sense. We glorify spending untold millions on fretting over dead people and watch our neighbor go unemployed for months. I could give crap about how many angels can dance on the head of a pin or any other lame doctrine that has no real substance. It is all just speculation anyway. My church would use all that business prowess to uplift and edify the members temporally above all else and I am convinced the spiritual part would automatically follow. It is hard for a man or woman to be spiritually edified when they are living under the stress of financial instability always. I say if you are the one true church prove it and alter the lives of your members with more than just talk and speculation about how wonderful everything is going to be if you just believe. Uplift your members and make their lives more than all other churches combined have ever done. Call on God to end the suffering and anxiety. Ask him for real direction on how to get us moving towards a real self sufficient society of equals.
November 4, 2012 at 10:52 pm #261288Anonymous
GuestCadence wrote: Quote:We glorify spending untold millions on fretting over dead people and watch our neighbor go unemployed for months. I could give crap about how many angels can dance on the head of a pin or any other lame doctrine that has no real substance. It is all just speculation anyway. My church would use all that business prowess to uplift and edify the members temporally above all else and I am convinced the spiritual part would automatically follow. It is hard for a man or woman to be spiritually edified when they are living under the stress of financial instability always.
I say if you are the one true church prove it and alter the lives of your members with more than just talk and speculation about how wonderful everything is going to be if you just believe. Uplift your members and make their lives more than all other churches combined have ever done. Call on God to end the suffering and anxiety. Ask him for real direction on how to get us moving towards a real self sufficient society of equals.
Thanks with the quote, I totally needed this. I like the speculation part. I use a similar line when people get off topic about stuff that doesn’t matter. I sometimes wonder how Zion will be “with no poor among them.” Will the poor somehow become rich because of the law of consecration, or will the poor be exiled and cast out as sinners. We never get the message on how Zion is to be accomplished. Whenever the law of consecration, or the United Order is mentioned, you always have the line that we are living it partially by 10% of tithing, and fast offerings that people pay. Yet, how many people that truly are suffering are helped. Working at DI or welfare square may help alleviate some need, but it still doesn’t get me to the place of self-sufficiency. One prophet even speaks out against self-sufficiency, but then we are told to be self-sufficient. Go figure.
I actually had an okay day today at church. It’s probably because I didn’t stay in charge beyond two hours, and I avoided all speculation and called an old friend on the phone that I haven’t spoken to for months. Oh well, I guess carpe diem, when it comes to my life. Something will happen, it always does. Sorry for my rants, but it helped me to blow off some steam.
November 5, 2012 at 12:10 am #261289Anonymous
GuestHi Jamison, I too have been unemployed and it scared the crap out of me. Now when someone critiques our children and my wife gets so upset I try to remind myself that she takes a significant part of her identity from her “home making” skill, just like I take a fair amount of my identity from providing.
You have my commiseration – that is definitely a tuff row to hoe.
I am reminded of something Brian had said to the effect that “God has a terrible track record of paying my bills on time.” I interpret that to mean that being devoted to the Gospel/church seems to have little or no correlation with financial blessings or even financial security. Some people that are having financial troubles see the promised blessings realized in other ways – like finding shoes that are my kid’s size in fair condition at a yard sale. I’m not going to dispute their interpretation of things (to their face), but I cannot see God’s intervention to help them find good deals at yard sales.
jamison wrote:So, I guess members should just stop paying tithing. I don’t see blessings from it. I just see luck of the draw.
I hit a similar roadblock. I remember saying explicitly that I can’t be everywhere for my kids and so I pay tithing to call down the blessings of heaven upon them – like big heavenly protector angels or a divine nanny-cam. When my daughter died, my illusion was shattered. My old reason for paying tithing (as the most painful outward observance for me personally to perform) was gone. I either needed to get a new reason or stop paying – pure and simple.
November 5, 2012 at 2:04 am #261290Anonymous
GuestFwiw, I don’t pay tithing for financial blessings – mostly because life has taught me that it’s not a cause and effect correlation. On the other hand, I don’t fault or criticize people whose lives have taught them it is such a correlation. November 6, 2012 at 2:44 pm #261291Anonymous
GuestI believe in the saying “give a man a fish feed him for a day. Teach a man to fish feed him for a lifetime.” The church can hand out all the fish it wants but in the end you will be hungry the next day. If you give out the fish everyday then you become dependent. This is why I strongly believe the focus of the church should be on enhancing the temporal lives of its members. I just seems this is how you really get to the hearts of men. November 7, 2012 at 2:52 am #261292Anonymous
GuestCadence wrote:I have often thought that the true church would have somehow figured out how to manage the temporal affairs of its members by now. It would have instituted job training, built industry to employ its many members, and become a business yes but one that caters to the needs of its members by providing quality employment. This would be the true church to me.
Makes me think of the historical Catholic church. While the masses did get proselytized, missionaries would focus on the kings, lords, ruling classes, etc., expecting (which bore out historically) that if the rulers converted, the people would too. The rulers would want to demonstrate their grandness and piety by building cathedrals and churches and lavishing riches on them, while the poor and destitute all around the sites would carry on with their downtrodden lives. This continued for centuries from the early 2nd century on.
Churches always benefit most (financially) by the wealthy who can afford to support their causes with their riches. Be it Christianity, Islam, Buddhism, etc., you will find gold, jewels and incense to show the grandeur of the religion and its worth to the faithful and to those who see it, but I always wonder how such great displays of wealth on BEHALF of a god could have done for the CHILDREN or creations of that god if it had been spent on them instead. Yes, we would have fewer statues, temples, churches, sacred buildings, but at certain times of history, how much suffering could have been otherwise alleviated?
Why? Is it easier to build a grand monument than to take care of others? Certainly, people believe they are venerating their god or religion by focusing on making THINGS rather than improving people, but would not true religion want to build its testament to their beliefs in the lives they improved rather than the gold they contributed?
On the other hand, human nature being what it is, wouldn’t all needy people see a church lifting people up and everyone scramble to get “in on the action” while it was still available? When does the religion stop being about helping raise other people and become a welfare state/dole that doesn’t do much to actually change the lives of the people it is attempting to reach?
[/endmusing] Sorry. I don’t really have an answer to the OP’s problem. Being out of work, especially as a guy, brings about all kinds of self-worth issues in addition to the practical day-to-day ones. Whether the Church is involved or the focus or not, it is hard for anyone to go through without trying to pick apart both the cause (initial) and the lack of relief (long term). Millions in all countries around the world are facing the issue and not finding a lot of solutions (not just the US. Think of Greece and Spain and elsewhere where unemployment is even greater). Each case is a study in personal suffering and emotional and physical loss – both of income and self worth. My only suggestion is to separate your sense of self-worth from your current lack of ability to provide for your family. You are still of worth irrespective of your paycheck. You have talents, skills, and experiences that no one else in the world has. There WILL come a time when someone will recognize your value to their endeavor and will offer you a job. That doesn’t help while you are going through it, but it HAS to change and will if you can just last long enough. The wait can seem interminable, but if you can find a way to believe in yourself, something WILL turn around. If you want to believe that God is responsible for that, good. If it is nature, fate, luck or chance, good too as long as it helps you get through to the light at the end of the current tunnel.
As someone who has long wrestled with issues of depression and self worth, I hope something of what I have said can help in some way. We are pulling for you!
November 7, 2012 at 5:17 pm #261293Anonymous
GuestQuote:Neither person will help the poor.
Bit of cross posting here…
I don’t know how right wing “Christians” manage to square their greed with not helping the poor. Maybe that’s why they’re so obsessed with Creationism, it distracts from the social gospel that Jesus preached.
More of my own comments –
http://forum.staylds.com/viewtopic.php?f=9&t=3763
Quote:Both Romney and Obama come from minorities that were previously oppressed. True, the Mormons never experienced slavery (neither did Obama’s ancestors by the way), but they were hounded out the USA to the frontier, and a number of people were murdered by both sides. I don’t think LDS suffering compares to that of the blacks in the USA, but it is worth mentioning the violence we once experienced. So both candidates represented something positive in that sense.
Personally, I have no interest in either the Demoblicans or the Republicrats, since I think that they represent a narrow slice of right wing opinion. A cosy consensus, more about personalities than genuine political difference. The USA seems to be the only country in which ordinary working people constantly vote against their own interests, and for those of the ruling plutocracy (big business). Obama’s most radical policy was blocked, and he seems to be doing the usual.
Obama, far from being some ghetto kid, actually comes from a pretty lofty family on his mother’s side. He is related to a number of major US politicians through his white mother…
Romney had some questionable banking interests overseas, but otherwise didn’t represent Mormonism that badly. I’m glad he didn’t come over as some complete nutcase, and that a lot of “Gentiles” obviously voted for him.
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.