Home Page › Forums › Introductions › Hello, I’m new here but hope to be a regular participant
- This topic is empty.
-
AuthorPosts
-
August 26, 2013 at 1:52 pm #207894
Anonymous
GuestHi, all. I’ve lurked here a bit since discovering the site somewhat accidentally. This appears to be the kind of site I am looking for. I am also a member of LDS.net, but my needs are not always met there and my ideas are not readily accepted there by most. I’ll give you a bit of background. I am a 52-year-old male, baptized into the church when I was 21 while serving in the army. I was a “golden” convert – I did know a few members of the church, but I did not ask them my questions, I researched myself (I loved
A Marvelous Work and a Wonder) and called the missionaries and asked to be baptized. Two years later I served a mission. I returned to my hometown, got a college degree, married in the temple to a wonderful woman, and we have four fantastic children (one a graduate of BYU another reporting to the mission field in October).
Just over 10 years ago I had what I call a crisis of faith. I found myself in a situation where I was questioning everything I believe about the church, religion in general, and even the existence of God. I was truly shaken to the core. I stopped going to church and have not returned since, although I think I may in the somewhat near future. Over the past couple of years I have partially “rebuilt” my faith, after having gone through pendulum swings from the extremes of God loving us and being intricately involved in our daily lives to God exists and is the creator but that’s all (a diest view). Many other gospel principles and religious beliefs have had similar pendulum swings (prayer, scriptures, etc.). I still lean toward the diest side of things (God does exist and does care about us, but is not involved in our daily lives), prayers are a form of worship but are not usually answered, and so forth. I still struggle with many LDS beliefs and have not reached my own middle ground on some principles yet. I don’t go to church because I have a hard time dealing with people who “know” many things that they really don’t know anything about. I don’t doubt their sincerity and I don’t doubt that they really think they know those things – I also “knew” many things to be true that I now doubt. I believe my thinking has matured to the point where I can ignore, if you will, these ideas just as I would anyone who believes differently than I on any host of subjects.
Part of the problem is that I live in a small ward in the eastern U.S., and while I’m sure the bishop will be accepting, I know I will still be struggling each day inside myself. If and when I do return (and do note that I have considered having my name removed in the past), it will be for sacrament meeting only.
So, all of that said, this place appears to be my kind of place. Other sites one finds while doing Google searches turn out to actually be anti-Mormon. I am not anti-Mormon, and believe in the basic principles of the gospel as taught by the LDS church – I just happen to believe they teach some things as gospel that aren’t gospel. How do all of you who are in my situation deal with going to church?
August 26, 2013 at 4:43 pm #272722Anonymous
GuestWelcome to the site! I grew up mostly in PA, so I am from back east too. Quote:I just happen to believe they teach some things as gospel that aren’t gospel. How do all of you who are in my situation deal with going to church?
It’s funny how the church expects such pure patriotism while having doctrines that evolve with our understanding. After all, we’re a church that embraces both ongoing institutional revelation and personal revelation, both of which imply that whatever came before was missing that understanding that is being added. And yet some members are so brittle in their testimony that they can’t brook any dissent or questioning or pointing out of contradictions.
I keep a sense of humor about it. I deal with people pragmatically, and I assume that if they had given it any thought they also would have a sense of humor about it and develop flexibility. That’s the approach I take in general. Even when I have a strong opinion, I can point out why it’s kind of obvious I would think that way. Someone once introduced me in RS as a feminist (it was someone I also know is a feminist) and I was a little rattled that this would be how I was introduced. I said, “Well, duh, we’re ALL feminists in here. We’re women. And we believe we are equal and should be treated as equals, right?” Nobody could argue with that one.
August 26, 2013 at 5:22 pm #272723Anonymous
GuestThanks, Hawkgrrrl for the reply. My BYU grad daughter is also a bit of a feminist, and struggles at times with her own questions. I like that you can give witty replies as you do, and I can usually come up with something witty also, but mine come a few hours late! 🙂 I agree with, it does at times amaze me how the church teaches the need for continuing revelation (and yes, evolution of thought), yet some members of the church are so rigid that any new or different thought is flatly rejected.
I have all of these years felt very alone. I am so happy I have found a place where I am understood and not alone.
August 26, 2013 at 6:41 pm #272724Anonymous
GuestDarkJedi wrote:How do all of you who are in my situation deal with going to church?
I attend SM and then go straight to work. Most people seem understanding. I put my work badge on as I’m leaving the building as a bit of display that I’m off to perform my other manly responsibilities.
When I get an extra day off and attend the full 3 hour block it is almost always disappointing. I believe this is because the format in SM is one way communication while there is supposed to be some give and take in the SS. It can be so very frustrating to self censor or to try to twist my comments into as faith promoting version as possible. It is also difficult to hear the “piccolos” monopolize the conversation.
I am fine with most other church activities and events. I don’t mind helping people move etc.
Welcome DarkJedi – you are among friends.
August 26, 2013 at 8:09 pm #272725Anonymous
GuestThanks. I don’t have a particular place to go when I leave after Sacrament Meeting, but I’m sure I’m not the only one who will be leaving also. Likewise, I don’t mind participating in most activities as long as the demands of those activities don’t unduly interfere with time with my family. Your comments about other meetings (SS, priesthood) are duly noted, and why I believe I probably won’t attend them. August 26, 2013 at 8:56 pm #272726Anonymous
GuestWelcome DarkJedi. I am also on lds.net, in fact, I used to be a moderator. I got sick of people being so black/white about issues that I left for a while. I slowly started coming back there a few months ago, but the situation is the same. There are a few that I would love, love, loveto tell off and it would so be worth getting banned for, but I don’t. I just come here and enjoy the civil discussions about various levels of belief and open conversations about the issues facing the church. Welcome.
August 26, 2013 at 9:03 pm #272727Anonymous
GuestMeh Mormon wrote:Welcome DarkJedi. I am also on lds.net, in fact, I used to be a moderator. I got sick of people being so black/white about issues that I left for a while. I slowly started coming back there a few months ago, but the situation is the same. There are a few that I would
love, love, loveto tell off and it would so be worth getting banned for, but I don’t. I just come here and enjoy the civil discussions about various levels of belief and open conversations about the issues facing the church. Welcome.
😆 I know exactly what you mean. I get good stuff from there, don’t get me wrong. My user name is very similar there (there’s an underscore between the words there), feel free to look at my posts. There’s a recent thread about referencing Christ in meetings that I responded to a couple times but won’t any more. How I would love to show a couple of moderators where the bear did you-know-what in the buckwheat, but I don’t want to be banned, either, because I do get something out of it. Being there has given me some insight into how I might handle those who see things from a very different point of view than I do.August 27, 2013 at 8:15 pm #272728Anonymous
GuestDarkJedi wrote:Just over 10 years ago I had what I call a crisis of faith. I found myself in a situation where I was questioning everything I believe about the church, religion in general, and even the existence of God. I was truly shaken to the core. I stopped going to church and have not returned since, although I think I may in the somewhat near future. Over the past couple of years I have partially “rebuilt” my faith, after having gone through pendulum swings from the extremes of God loving us and being intricately involved in our daily lives to God exists and is the creator but that’s all (a diest view).
DarkJedi,
You had mentioned elsewhere that church history was never really a problem for you. Would it be too pushy to ask what the catalyst was for your faith crisis 10 years ago?
It also seems that your family has remained active. How did you go about sharing with your family that your faith had changed, how was it received then and how have things gone over the years?
Thanks!
August 27, 2013 at 8:58 pm #272729Anonymous
GuestHi Roy, nice to meet you. No, it’s not too forward to ask although it’s a bit complicated and I like to maintain some privacy in the matter. Very briefly, and it is much more complicated than this, back in 2000 I endeavored on a new career path which required that I get more education which I did at some sacrifice to my then young family. I interned and was offered a position where I interned. I was happy there, but saw the opportunity for growth in another nearby organization. Being that I was happy, I prayed and fasted quite fervently to know if I should follow those promptings and received what I believed was an overwhelming positive response. I compare it to the same feeling I had when I was taught the first discussion, at my subsequent baptism, at my temple sealing, and other very spiritual times. I felt it really was that profound. I got the other job handily – I was by far the most qualified candidate. Because this is relevant to the story later, I’ll tell you now that my bishop was on the board of that organization but had nothing to do with my hiring – he was away at the time. This was a management position, but what I didn’t know was that there was someone else in house that this organization was grooming for the position and I was a place holder for him while he got the education he needed. He was, in fact, my assistant. In retrospect I realize every other key player, including the bishop, knew this. Two years later he was ready and I was fired, and even though this was a major blow, I was OK with it – God wanted me to do this, so there must be a purpose and he must have a way out of it for me. Long story short, he didn’t. My career had ended. I had been betrayed by the bishop, who was also my friend – I had been his counselor and served with him as counselors in another bishopric, and I had been betrayed by God. This is a very political industry, and things like this matter. I have not since found meaningful employment in the field.
Therein is the crisis of faith – I no longer knew what to believe. Had God really directed me there, knowing this would be the outcome? If he didn’t, and I misinterpreted the impressions and promptings, how do I know what is from God and what isn’t? Is the Book of Mormon really nor true? Is the church really not true? Can I not trust friends and leaders in the church? (The bishop’s answer when confronted, by the way, was “I’m sorry, I should have told you.”) Again, it’s more involved and complicated than this – it would take pages to fully describe all that happened. And I did not immediately stop going to church – I continued for over a year while all the time the questions grew more profound and expanded and the answers were becoming undeniable. I did not feel what I thought was the influence of the Holy Ghost anymore, and still don’t.
Family has been a whole different story. My wife, in fact, has not been very understanding and it has put a great deal of stress on our marriage and on our family. We don’t have discussions on the subject and have not in many years because she is argumentative toward the few new views I have shared – she is an unquestioning TBM. She does not know I am considering returning to church. So, things have not gone well over the years, and while my daughter (now grown) and sons regularly participated in church activities, I did not, although I do attend some social functions. I do not participate in family prayers, FHE (which we really don’t have), mealtime prayers, etc. I have not participated in the ordinations of my sons nor the baptism of the youngest – and frankly, I am hurt by that. The eldest son is preparing for a mission and will be going to the temple soon, I will not be participating.
I still have lots of things to sort out and rebuild as
myfaith. August 27, 2013 at 9:40 pm #272730Anonymous
GuestWelcome. I am checking in in spots only and can’t type long comments, but I do want to welcome you. August 27, 2013 at 9:43 pm #272731Anonymous
GuestOld-Timer wrote:Welcome. I am checking in in spots only and can’t type long comments, but I do want to welcome you.
Thank you, Ray. I did read your post about your father.I have lost my parents and know what it’s like. Please accept my heartfelt sympathies.August 27, 2013 at 10:10 pm #272732Anonymous
GuestFunny how similar we are in our journeys. I knew about some of the funny church history stuff but it didn’t matter. If the power of God is real in my life, what does it matter what happened in ancient history. Then our third child was stillborn and it tore the heart out of all my assumptions. Does God bless us? how? based on what? There are so many church stories where God intervened in a tangible way for a preferred outcome. Was that all BS? I now somewhat envy people who are so sure that God has a purpose for this particular life decision or that. I second guess everything. Making decisions on my best information is unsettling at times but taking ownership for my decisions is a two way street.
My kids are still small and I’m trying to involve gospel moments into their upbringing. I plan to perform the baptisms and I give father’s blessings. I would love to give DS the priesthood when the time comes because my priesthood line of authority comes down our family line. We do family prayer and I usually pray for things that we can influence. I often pray that we will have a spirit of love in our home and that we might be accepting, patient, and forgiving of each other. My prayers are like stated hopes and dreams for my family. I try not to pray for specific events or outcomes but old habits can be hard to break.
Once again – welcome!
August 28, 2013 at 5:43 am #272733Anonymous
GuestDarkJedi wrote:Therein is the crisis of faith – I no longer knew what to believe. Had God really directed me there, knowing this would be the outcome? If he didn’t, and I misinterpreted the impressions and promptings,
how do Iknow what isfrom God and what isn’t?Is the Book of Mormon really nor true? Is the church really not true? Can I not trust friends and leaders in the church? (The bishop’s answer when confronted, by the way, was “I’m sorry, I should have told you.”) Again, it’s more involved and complicated than this – it would take pages to fully describe all that happened. And I did not immediately stop going to church – I continued for over a year while all the time the questions grew more profound and expanded and the answers were becoming undeniable. I did not feel what I thought was the influence of the Holy Ghost anymore, and still don’t. Glad you found staylds, DarkJedi!
Part of the answer for me has been to simply ask fewer questions. I’ve stopped seeking to “feel the spirit” all the time. I know that sounds bad, and maybe it’s a phase, but it’s where my journey has me at the moment. My prayers are heavier on thanks, and lighter on direction-seeking. I have callings and think I actually serve more genuinely than before. But there’s a different quality to the whole thing now. I knew something was up when I realized that I (I’d always been on the emotional side at church) hadn’t shed a tear for a year. And I’m fine with that. I guess what I’m saying is that looking
back, I don’t know what was from God and what wasn’t, but I feel like I know better going forwardhow to tell the difference. Still not perfectly, but better. August 28, 2013 at 12:42 pm #272734Anonymous
GuestThanks again, Roy. I, too, now struggle to make decisions, something I never really did in the past because I relied on God. I don’t feel I can do that any more – had I not followed what I thought were undeniable promptings and confirmations I would likely still be at my job previous and wold likely be happy – and active in the church. My beliefs about church history haven’t changed, actually. If Joseph Smith was a prophet (and I believe he was), then it just plain doesn’t matter to me. Ann, thanks for the welcome. Prayer is one of the big things I struggle with. I haven’t discovered the middle way for me yet, I guess. I’m currently somewhere in the area of prayers being nothing more than a form of worship. It’s pretty clear to me that prayers are not generally answered. I do believe some people’s prayers are answered but I believe it is rare and much of what people attribute to answers to prayers are nothing more than coincidence or things that would have happened anyway in the natural order of things. Sometimes it’s just that they
wantthe prayer to be answered, so in their minds and feelings, it is. Truth is, I rarely pray and I have given up on asking for anything – even the simplest of things or general blessings. I think that part of my faith may take the longest to rebuild. August 28, 2013 at 5:50 pm #272735Anonymous
GuestDark Jedi, I’m on lds.net too. Though intermittently. Same user name. It was actually a fellow called Snow over there who helped me see that same sex marriage under the law is separate from one’s religious beliefs about such marriages. Good guy, I miss him and wish I had an email address. Alas. I find it interesting that you are making the assumption that you would have been happy at your previous job and still there. Perhaps that’s not at all what would have happened.
I know that prayer works. In one of the darkest times of my life I prayed daily. My husband wanted a divorce which turned a two year separation during which time we reconciled and got back together. I prayed to be calm of heart and clear of mind. To know what to do for my husband and when and how to do what’s needed. To know what to say, when to say it, how to say it, and when to be silent. This is not to say I did not have times where I fell apart, I did. But it happened less frequently after two weeks of not being able to eat (it was a good day to eat half a health bar). There were times where I just wanted to lambaste him in reaction to my pain, but these prayers kept me in check and helped me to remember that he was hurting too.
In a blessing that I gave to my daughter, she was told the following, “do not pray for conveniences.” We were both surprised by that one. What is interesting, upon sudden reflection as I type this, is that the prayers I offered during my time of tribulation with my husband were anything but convenient. It took a lot of hard work and mindfulness. It totally would’ve been easier to divorce him, mourn a little bit, and then find someone to marry in the Temple (my husband is not Mormon). But that’s not at all what God wanted me to do.
It seems that God does not want us to have easy lives but to have lives full of reciprocal blessings.
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.