- This topic is empty.
-
AuthorPosts
-
September 22, 2013 at 6:01 pm #207998
Anonymous
GuestHi all, I have some questions about the temple. I didn’t know if I should start a new topic or not, so I did anyway. When I was a BYU student our bishop called us to be temple missionaries. This just meant that we went to the temple once a week. So I went once a week for at least a year, maybe two. At first I prayed to understand what was being taught, the symbolism, etc. I was always uncomfortable. Never at ease, except when I was tired and would half fall asleep. After awhile I stopped trying to understand and I went instead with the purpose of feeling the spirit. I felt peaceful outside of the temple on the grounds and still do. But I rarely feel peaceful inside. I know the usual answer would be I didn’t have faith, but I truly believed I would feel something. Another question I have is why women are queens to their husbands in heaven but husbands are not kings to us. They are kings to God. To me this is a subtle, but clear message. I sometimes repent for being a women because I know for some reason we are less in some way. And what’s really depressing is it continues in the next life. So even though we’re told everyone’s equal, this doesn’t show in the temple.
The other thing that I don’t understand is why everyone is white Anglo-Saxon in the temple movie. I know there’s a new movie and I haven’t seen it but have been told there’s no diversity. The church leaders seem so proud of our international presence and yet when there’s a chance to show how international we are we exclude all races but one. To me it’s another subtle message that white is best. Do the leaders honestly believe that white is the best representative of all mankind? Anywho, those are my questions about the temple. Thanks for reading
September 22, 2013 at 7:44 pm #274143Anonymous
GuestHi Haven, Allow me to give my own thoughts…
Haven wrote:I sometimes repent for being a women because I know for some reason we are less in some way. And what’s really depressing is it continues in the next life.
How can you repent for being a woman but then remain as a woman? Is it just to feel bad for being a woman? I’m not much for feeling bad over things that I have no control over. I’m getting pretty tired of hearing about perfection. Is sin the opposite of perfection? I agree that you are not perfect, but I do believe that you are who you were made to be. You are the best at being you and in that way are fulfilling the measure of your creation.
I gave a talk in SM about being different and my feelings about it not too long ago. You can follow the link if you are interested.
http://forum.staylds.com/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=2542 As for specific wordings and lack of diversity in the temple – I explain all that to be culturally influenced and not really part of the core gospel.
Welcome to the group.
September 22, 2013 at 10:22 pm #274144Anonymous
GuestQuote:To me it’s another subtle message that white is best. Do the leaders honestly believe that white is the best representative of all mankind?
No, I don’t believe so. I think they just don’t think about it. I think that’s the same general answer to the question about the wording that is troubling to many women. I think it will change in the future, but it probably will take more than just a few years.
I would favor movies in each country that have native members from that country. In the case of the United States, that would include multiple races and ethnic heritages. That way, each race and ethnicity would see God as looking like them.
I know the most powerful experience I have had in the temple was decades ago in the Atlanta Temple, when the Lord reached through the veil – and the hand was black.
September 22, 2013 at 11:19 pm #274145Anonymous
GuestHaven wrote:Another question I have is why women are queens to their husbands in heaven but husbands are not kings to us. They are kings to God. To me this is a subtle, but clear message.
I hope I live to see a change. This sounds flippant, but, bottom line, I just don’t think this is going to fly anymore. The “subtle” message screams to women now.
The new film is more diverse, but I don’t happen to feel as strongly about that. Someone has to portray the characters. No matter what the ethnicity of the cast members, someone is not represented. But I wish for words that portray God’s love for all men – and women – and their equal standing before Him.
September 23, 2013 at 1:13 am #274146Anonymous
GuestI never really enjoyed the temple. I find it’s a drain on my time. For some reason, I’m not fully self-aware of the things I do in the temple, and people are always correcting me about nitty picky things. My worst experience was being a veil worker. I went once. During that time I was corrected about 5 times and then chastised as we sat in the waiting room for explaining something related to a ticket I received for speeding when others were talking about it. So, the temple is one thing that I’ve decided is not a big part of my life anymore. I have better, more spiritual experiences sharing my thoughts online and then reflecting on them, serving others in non-church contexts, and having meaningful discussions with my family. I suppose if there was a place near my house where I could go to sit peacefully, that would meet every bit of “need” I have for a temple experience. I once thought of having a little outbuilding that was decorated nicely and peacefully where I could read and think and pray, independent of technology and distractions. It would be every bit as good as the temple.
September 23, 2013 at 3:11 am #274147Anonymous
GuestLike SD, I never enjoyed the temple, either. Sure, it’s a very beautiful and peaceful place and I do feel peace there. I’m not like those who get something new out of it every time I visit – I don’t think I have gotten anything new since my first visit. I actually find a similar peace being alone in the outdoors. I never really thought about the female perspective in temple before seeing some mentions of it on these forums, and frankly never paid that much attention to the wording. Now that I have thought about it, I do understand why some women feel the way they do about the temple. I do believe it is LDS doctrine that men and women are equal, and I am also very aware that the temple ceremony changes from time to time (I first went when there were penalties). I’m not sure why they have not seen fit to change the wording regarding women, but I hope that at some point they will. As for the actors, I don’t think that is really intentional, I don’t think they give it a second thought actually. Most policies of the church seem to revolve around the LDS culture in Utah, which is predominantly white. It would seem to me that the church should have had a South American apostle by now – I guess it depends on who you know.
September 23, 2013 at 3:24 am #274148Anonymous
GuestHaven, I think it is important to distinguish between questions and criticisms. Either is fine, but confusing the two leads to frustration. Questioning is how we determine what we do believe, criticizing is how we separate ourselves from what we don’t believe.
When it comes to the temple, I think the most rewarding course of action is to figure out what you believe, and then see if and how the temple supports your beliefs. If the temple supports your beliefs, then it’s easy to overlook 19th-century constructs. If it doesn’t support your beliefs, then don’t go to the temple. Pretty simple really. There are elements of the Church I love and other elements I dislike strongly. I find calm by putting more weight on the things I love.
FWIW, I haven’t been to the temple since the 90’s. My reasons are different from yours. Each person has to find what works for them.
September 23, 2013 at 3:28 am #274149Anonymous
GuestRoy wrote:I agree that you are not perfect, but I do believe that you are who you were made to be. You are the best at being you and in that way are fulfilling the measure of your creation.
I listen to a lot of talk radio some of the time is spent listening to christian talk. One I heard, the I latched onto was the “Mom Show”. It had a show about advertising and young girls. It talked about the Jerry McGuire show when Jerry said “you complete me” and how advertising wants you to think that you are not complete with out their product.All that said to make this point – we may not be perfect, but we are complete. Meaning we are the way we are for a reason and there is nothing, no boy, girl, teacher, boss, anyone who can “make us complete”.
Now that is said –
Holy Cow! I knew others existed out there who didn’t like the temple endowments, but I didn’t know any of them …. now I do. When I did go (it’s been a long time), I just help with baptisms as that is the only part that makes any sense to me. The rest is a bunch of wibbly wobbly gibbly gobbly wooshy stuff (yes, that is a reference to one of my favorite shows).
September 23, 2013 at 4:10 am #274150Anonymous
GuestI went to the Temple recently with the youth of our ward. It was a great experience. I took some names of my family with us.
The experience was great because I could talk to the YW & say, this is my Great Grandmother, this is my Grandmother,
these are my Aunts. I knew some of these people personally.
Some of the girls in our group were daughters of our HT. (that was special too.)
It made the experience more personal.
I’ve decided I’m not going to the temple again unless I can take the names of relatives with me.
September 23, 2013 at 7:38 pm #274151Anonymous
GuestI so appreciate hearing from those who struggle with their feelings about the temple on this forum. Because you are brought up from a small child to view the temple as the pinnacle of spirituality, it can be confusing and a real let down if your experience does not gel with what most members seem to be saying. If your temple experiences are very strange to you, or not spiritual, your first inclination is to think something is wrong with yourself. You think you need to repent more or be more worthy or something. So, you try harder, go again, and it still does not feel right or good to you. So, then you begin to wonder if you are in the story of “The Emperor Has No Clothes.” Yet, too afraid to say anything. My husband’s first experience felt like he had just gone through a “Klu, Klux, Klan” meeting. So, how do you deal with it when it does not feel right or spiritual to you as it does the others? Are some members just talking themselves into it feeling spiritual or are they ‘pretending’ so they can fit in. I do not have a problem with the genealogy or proxy work per se, but never got a testimony of all the other commitments or covenants. Just seemed nonspiritual and strange to my husband and I. And believe me, we fasted and prayed each time before we went to get a testimony of the temple. September 23, 2013 at 7:47 pm #274152Anonymous
GuestMike’s and Bridget’s experiences are great examples of how individuals react differently to the same situations – and how it’s important to acknowledge and accept that. Some people simply can’t attend the temple without extreme negative reactions; others can attend despite not loving it or having a “witness” of any kind about it; others enjoy the quiet escape from “the world”; others absolutely love it. None of those feelings and reactions are false or wrong. They are what they are, and we are left, individually, to figure out how to deal with our own feelings and reactions in the way that makes the most sense for us, individually.
September 23, 2013 at 9:21 pm #274153Anonymous
GuestThank You Ray, I wish all members were as respectful and understanding as you! September 23, 2013 at 9:44 pm #274154Anonymous
GuestI have always enjoyed being in the temple, and the peaceful feeling there. I view it completely symbolic. Those symbols have meant different things to me over different times in my life. Same materials, but just internalizing them differently.
I have had some questions similar to yours, and I am not sure there are “answers” to them…but more the exercise that having it cause you to search and study it out in your mind, and seek more information to help you think through those things…that is where it is helpful. You can get a different point of view on things, and the truths taught can be so different depending on your point of view.
Use those questions to study. Seek out new ideas and new perspectives (like you are doing here). But always remember they are symbolic stories intended to teach us. It isn’t always important what the answers are, but what questions you are asking.
I do not believe in a heaven where women are subject to men, or less than, or cannot get to God unless they go through a man. I can speculate why the temple is written the way it is with rituals the way they are, but I don’t believe heaven is a place where men rule over women. Not everything in the temple needs to be viewed as the way it literally will be in heaven or with God.
September 24, 2013 at 8:29 am #274155Anonymous
GuestI was very excited when I first attended the temple, and decided to take out my endowments in SLC and have a live session. I just figured that was how my grandparents had experienced it, so I wanted to also. I understood there was a lot of symbolism and went in with a very open mind. I worked really hard at being prepared and being worthy and prayerful beforehand. It was just so completely foreign to me, that instead of a spiritual experience, I had a big headache, and had to have reassurance that what I was experiencing and seeing was completely normal. It was nothing like I expected. I wouldn’t recommend a live session. I have gone again, with a bit more success, but the only peace I feel there is in the celestial room. It has made me feel a bit inadequate when I hear how wonderful many people find the temple to be. I really try to be prepared. I don’t have a recommend right now since it expired recently, and I’m not super motivated to get it renewed at this point. It is helpful to hear others who have had similar feelings. The sealing ceremony was a bit underwhelming also, but I was very happy to be sealed to my husband. I remember my mom having similar feelings about the temple. She was often told she would find her answers in the temple, and she would tell me that it just didn’t work out that way for her. Maybe it runs in the family.
Guess I should try again. We have had such a hard year this year maybe I could get some peace and reassurance this time. It did feel a bit like the emperor’s new clothes” to me too. Am I doing something wrong?
Also, I picked the name Harmony because that is what I am searching for in relation to my beliefs about the gospel and my questions and conflicts. I don’t have it yet, but I’m working on it. : )
September 24, 2013 at 2:42 pm #274156Anonymous
GuestHarmony wrote:It was just so completely foreign to me
Harmony,I know exactly what you mean. It is very
foreignto members of the Church going though it for the first time. I was fully faithful when I went through it and it was a shock to the system. I did learn to love it however. Well… I never loved the ceremony itself, but I loved participating in it. The thing that struck me was how completely unlikeour religion the temple is. We have very low symbolism in our Church. Our church buildings are plain. We don’t have crosses, even. We tend to be agreeable to symbolism, but superficially. We treat doctrines as matter-of-fact declarations without delving into layers. What does it mean to be baptized? We never ask ourselves this in the Church… instead we say it is for remission of sins and talk about the importance of our Church having the authority to do it. We read the parables of Jesus with a yawn and skip directly to the explanation of it as described by some GA. We are also very short on ritual. The only ritual we perform outside the temple is the Sacrament, and that is brief, quiet, and sandwiched between the announcements and the first talk. The sacrament in our Church is very nearly an afterthought in its own “sacrament” meeting. So, when we go to the temple and the whole thing is a symbolic rite, it is… disorienting. Outside the temple, our Church is the model of simplicity and straight-forward-ness… kind of blue-collar. Meat-and-potatoes. Down-to-earth. Then you go to the temple and it’s all ritualistic clothing, gestures, sayings, and symbolism. The disconnect couldn’t be bigger. Harmony wrote:Am I doing something wrong?
Absolutely not. I think you have to think of the temple as a form of worship and worship has to come from your heart. If you don’t feel it, it serves no purpose. Don’t worry about what others say. If the temple works for you, great, if it doesn’t, great, too. Just find something else that does work for you.One thing I’d suggest before you go to the temple again (if you go) is to go to a couple of Catholic masses. Observe the people there, and the rite of the mass. Then just project that onto the temple. The endowment ceremony is a similar ritual, but instead of belonging to the Catholics, it belongs to us.
Finally, on symbolism. We make the mistake in our church of trying to understand everything literally. We try to answer unanswerable questions, and when we get to the Book of Revelation, we pull out Cleon Skousen or Bruce McConkie, because we want to understand what the 7 horns mean. Symbolism shouldn’t work that way. Symbols are supposed to be vague. In this way, we can find whatever meaning we want to in them. Good symbols typically have multi-layered meanings, and what one person sees in a symbol might be different from what another sees. Is baptism to ‘wash’ away sins, or is it to be buried with Christ. It is whichever works for you. If I say, “The game of baseball is a metaphor for life” you probably will say, “I see what you mean”, yet I have said nothing about HOW baseball is a metaphor for life. What do the bases represent? What does the bat represent? Why are their 9 players? Why is the ball white with stitches? You can go on the idea that baseball is a metaphor for life and carry that to whatever level you want, to whatever makes sense to you, to whatever makes you stronger in life. The symbols are vague. That’s the same way religious symbols are. What does the sacrament represent? Is it the death of Jesus or the life that he gives us? Is it the body and blood of Christ or is t the Bread of Life (John 6) and the Living Water (John 4)? So, when it comes to the temple, step back. Take the long view. Think about what the temple ceremony represent to you in the large. Then build your own symbology around it.
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.