Home Page Forums Introductions Newbie, coming through :-P

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 28 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #209389
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Hi i’m newish to the church. I was baptized about 4 years ago, but went inactive 3.5 years ago, because i couldn’t find answers to my questions. When i tried asking members of the church i was shut down very quickly, and gossiped about just as quickly. Recently on impulse and on the recommendation of a exmo friend i sent in my disassociation papers, but i am now regretting that and waiting to speak to my local bishop. Despite all my doubts i still get the nagging and in-explainable guttural feeling that the church is true, which to be honest drives me insane, i was a devout Jehovah witness, till age 24 I’m now 31. Those 24 years were soul destroying and very nearly sent me insane, so i hate the idea of belonging to any church and am easily put off by negative church culture, that might impact badly on my mental health. And yet here i am, searching for answers to explain my guttural feeling and hoping at least that if the church is true, i might find peace with it’s less pleasant parts and in belonging to another organised religion and do so without going religiously insane. Thankfully this time round i stumbled on mormondialogue.com and this site, previously when trying to find answers all i had found was fair mormons wiki page and Mormon think as a newbie i often need a translator to explain what fair mormon are talking about, but found the missionaries were often unwilling to discus said topics even if there from fair mormon. Mormon think is easy to understand but imo riddled with bias and inconsistencies. Anywho i’m here now and hoping i will find this site a good place to discuss questions i might from a lds point of view.

    Bec :D

    #292624
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Welcome. We totally understand angst here. The events may be different as well as the questions, but we will do what we can. Good luck with your Bishop meeting and any decisions you make going forward. I will send prayers on your behalf.

    #292625
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Welcome, Bec.

    I’m glad you found us and hope we can help in whatever way you need.

    #292628
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Was your named removed from the records of the church, or are you in the process and wanting to withdraw the disassociation papers, as you call them, before it goes to an actual name removal?

    In any case, thanks for coming here and entrusting us with your story. Looking forward to helping you stay in spite of your misgivings and concerns.

    #292626
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Welcome. This is a good and safe place to discuss difficult topics and ask hard questions. I’m not sure we can actually answer any question, but we can help you find what works for you. I, too, hope all goes well with your bishop. You didn’t share what you put in your letter, but either way do be careful what you share with your bishop – I recommend being as vague as possible. I hope you find the peace you seek.

    #292627
    Anonymous
    Guest

    DarkJedi wrote:

    be careful what you share with your bishop – I recommend being as vague as possible. I hope you find the peace you seek.

    I would second that. I would emphasize how (as you said), you “feeling and hoping at least that if the church is true.”

    #292629
    Anonymous
    Guest

    I thought i’d follow up with a “what’s happened so far” I was too sick on Sunday to make it to church, i woke with a migraine and spent the day vomiting, I’ve been under the weather ever since. So i didn’t get a chance to visit with my bishop but he did call me tonight, unfortunately i missed that call as i’d turned my phone off, because i was resting, by the time i checked my phone it was 10pm and i didn’t want to call at that hour, so i’ll try him tomorrow and hopefully we’ll catch each other.

    For what it’s worth this was my disassociation letter and my subsequent “I’ve changed my mind letter” I thought i’d share it with you since people have asked. The disassociation letter is a copy of the one my exmo friend gave me to send in.

    Quote:

    This letter is my formal resignation from the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and it is effective immediately. I hereby withdraw my consent to being treated as a member and I withdraw my consent to being subject to church rules, policies, beliefs and ‘discipline’. As I am no longer a member, I want my name permanently and completely removed from the membership rolls of the church.

    I have given this matter considerable thought. I understand what you consider the ‘seriousness’ and the ‘consequences’ of my actions. I am aware that the church handbook says that my resignation “cancels the effects of baptism and confirmation, withdraws the priesthood held by a male member and revokes temple blessings” I also understand that I will be “readmitted to the church by baptism only after a thorough interview”.

    Let me make myself clear, I DO NOT BELIVE IN JOSEPH SMITH, THE PROPHETS, OR APOSTLES!!! I DO NOT BELIEVE IN CREATION AND I DO NOT BELIVE IN THE CHURCH, THERE IS NO SALVATION THROUGH LDS INC!!! The church is an abusive cult like religion preying on members and society for its own financial gains.

    My resignation should be processed immediately, without any ‘waiting periods’. I am not going to be dissuaded and I am not going to change my mind.

    I expect this matter to be handled promptly, with respect and with full confidentiality.

    After today, the only contact I want from the church is a single letter of confirmation to letting me know that I am no longer listed as a member of the church.

    Any member attempting to visit me at my home will be arrested and prosecuted for stalking harassment and trespassing. NO means NO, LDS members are NOT exempt from obeying my NO RELIGIOUS CALLERS and NO CANVASERS SIGNS!!!

    You legally have 72 hours to remove my name from your records as I waive your 30 day holding period policy. Refusing to or ignoring my request for resignation will also be prosecuted under article 18 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights by the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission (HREOC).

    Sincerely,

    This is my “i’ve changed my mind letter”

    Quote:

    I am wondering if it is possible to withdraw my “withdrawal” from membership of the church? I recently wrote in using a letter given to me by a friend to withdraw my membership from the church, however it has come to my attention that the information given to me by my friend about the church may not be accurate. I have begun reading Mormon think for myself and I am finding many inconsistencies and “cherry picked” arguments. For example, my friend and Mormon think claim Joseph was a great story teller and thus the book of Mormon is just another work of fiction like for example Lord of the Rings. But after checking for myself I find the “great stories” they claim, Joseph’s mother talked about, were in fact BOM stories and only started after the first vision. They also claim Joseph copied much of the BOM from the book “View of the Hebrews” but then claim that book was only released 5 years before the BOM. The arguments make no sense, either Joseph began citing BOM stories as a kid after the first vision, as his mother claimed or, he copied the whole BOM from another book. They also claim Joseph could not have been as illiterate as Emma and others stated because both Joseph Snr and Hyrum were part time school teachers, but why then did they not also teach him proper grammar. I am yet to meet a teacher who isn’t a “grammar nazi”

    Mormon think and my friend claim that if one problem can be found then surely that brings into question the whole LDS teachings, by that definition I can apply the same theory to Mormon think and my friends’ logic. Currently I am not personally sure what to believe, I was a Jehovah witnesses till the age of 24 and spent 7 years in full time preaching service to them. Losing my faith was one of the most traumatic experiences of my life, I would not wish that loss and subsequent emptiness on anyone, but for the same reason I am hesitant to blindly follow another religious organisation. I have often felt that I was baptised too soon and before I had a proper knowledge and foundation in the LDS faith, but similarly I am not now comfortable to hastily remove my name from your membership records on what now appears to be the illegitimate heresy of a friend. I would like therefore to cancel, my request to withdraw my membership from the church.

    Kind Regards

    Hopefully it’s enough for the Bishop to at least consider re-instating me

    #292630
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Please understand I am pretty blunt sometimes, and the next paragraph is not pointed at you directly. :D

    That is a lousy letter of resignation, frankly. That’s not your fault, necessarily, since you didn’t write it, but I have to say it’s one of the worst letters of resignation I’ve ever read. It’s extreme, in almost every way imaginable, and highly offensive to any regular member, much less one who believes passionately. It might as well call the person getting it a mindless sheep and a pig, since it will cause that same reaction. It also is inaccurate from a legal standpoint, and threats like that only alienate people who know they are unenforceable.

    I hope your Bishop understands and works with you. Exactly what happens will depend largely on if he followed-up immediately and if your name actually was removed from the records of the Church. If that happened, you will need to be rebaptized – which wouldn’t be a terrible thing, since it would give you a chance to slow down and make the decision in a more deliberate manner. If your name was not removed, that would remove the rebaptism requirement and allow you to slow down and figure things out better for yourself. Either way, it’s the slowing down and gaining your own perspective that is critical.

    I hope we can help in that process.

    #292631
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Hi Ray,

    Thank you for your bluntness, i appreciate it! I don’t always understand tact. :-)

    Apparently that letter is the standard letter on mormon think, It’s also on almost every ex-mo forum site out there. I googled exit letters to compare and all i found was this one. So touch wood, the church is so used to receiving these letters, my bishop will recognize i did not write it. I was informed by my friend these “legal letters” are the only ones the LDS church understands, hence the tone but as for the legitimacy of it, i don’t know anything about that. At the time, i simply didn’t want members calling or visiting me all the time trying to change my mind, i didn’t want to have to explain myself but also i have chronic health issues and random drop ins, regular visits, calls etc..really are too much for me to cope with, even my friends won’t do that. A bishop once told me, in comparison to the Jehovah witnesses process of “shunning” members, that mormons prefer to “love bomb” members into repentance, that is why i was concerned about excessive visitation and phone calls, because a previous bishop had told me that is what happens.

    That all aside i do believe my name had already been removed from the members list, because i can no longer log in online. I am yet to receive any letter confirming that but …

    I will return my bishops call in the morning and hopefully we can find a time to talk.

    #292632
    Anonymous
    Guest

    I agree the letter was pretty rough. I would have made it short and sweet without the digs against the church. I hope it works out and he can reverse the decision. In his position…I would in fact reverse it…but would likely have you on a short leash afterwards as I wouldn’t be sure of your commitment. The leaders I have worked with would likely consult their stake president if the removal had already been processed as I am not aware of any standardized policy on this. My hope would be that I could just reverse it and then work with you on strengthening your understanding and faith.

    Sent from my XT1080 using Tapatalk

    #292633
    Anonymous
    Guest

    I guess it was a little late for the “be careful what you share” advice. I hope your bishop is the understanding and forgiving type and that he did not do as you asked and immediately process the request. I would expect that no matter what you will be under the microscope for some time – and if your request was processed I think there will be a waiting period of at least a year for rebaptism and there will be some requirements before that happens.

    That said, we’re still here and we are willing to help you at least as much as you are willing to help yourself.

    #292634
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Old-Timer wrote:

    That is a lousy letter of resignation, frankly.

    I think you were supposed to print that out on paper with 1 finger salute as a watermark! :D

    Good luck NewB :)

    #292635
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Just wanted to say hello, beccaboo, and I hope things are working themselves out.

    #292636
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Hey Bec, here’s a late welcome to the forum for you.

    Interesting resignation letter. I almost feel like writing a much more professional resignation letter for people to use if that’s the only thing that’s out there; kind of a weird desire, but it’s in my nature, I guess.

    beccaboo wrote:

    When i tried asking members of the church i was shut down very quickly, and gossiped about just as quickly.


    You definitely aren’t the first and won’t be the last. One of my dearest friends left the church very young because of the cultural taboo against asking certain questions. Hopefully one day we can get that to change.

    I hope you are able to find what you are looking for, either here or elsewhere. Peace can be difficult to find, but it’s definitely not impossible.

    #292637
    Anonymous
    Guest

    I spoke to my bishop this afternoon, he said i will need to meet with him and the stake president but he will look into reinstatement. As a police officer, he recognized that the disassociation letter was not written by a person but most likely a organisation, so he wasn’t surprised when i told him it was given to me by someone who found it on Mormon think. Because of the nature of the letter and his job, he wasn’t able to perform the usual practice of meeting with me prior to resignation as such he is not sure if the resignation can be rescinded or not. Either way i will still need to meet with him and the stake president, so when he has a time, he will call me back to arrange a meeting.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 28 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.