Home Page › Forums › General Discussion › Merit Badge Counselor
- This topic is empty.
-
AuthorPosts
-
April 25, 2016 at 2:04 am #210701
Anonymous
GuestBishop caught me in the hall and suggested I consider being a Merit Badge Counselor. He said I only have to do something twice a year, but it was a short conversation. Can anyone enlighten me what this position is within the Scouting organization, what it involves, if it’s a formal calling, and the kind of time commitment required to do it well?
I’ve never heard of it before, even after taking basic Scouting training years and years ago.
Thanks,
April 25, 2016 at 2:53 am #311035Anonymous
GuestYou will meet with the boys if they are taking the merit badge you are a counselor for. It requires that you familiarize yourself with the requirements of the merit badge and maybe even participate in a merit badge clinic where you knock out a bunch of requirements with a group at a time. They do have an entrepreneurship merit badge. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
April 25, 2016 at 11:11 am #311036Anonymous
GuestI wouldn’t classify merit badge counselor as an official church calling, it’s a volunteer thing within the scouting organization. Not to seed your thoughts in any one particular direction but non-members can be given “callings” within the scouting arm of the church. I only mention that to underscore the separation. There are callings related to scouts like scoutmaster, den mother, some YM callings have expectations that the person will also be active with the scouts, etc. but given the time commitment of a merit badge counselor I wouldn’t put it down as a calling. More of a responsibility that comes up from time to time. As a merit badge counselor you’ll need approval from the local BSA council. It may vary from council to council but from what I’ve seen the approval process consists of filling out a form. As a BSA volunteer you will also be required to be current with their youth protection training. That may be the twice per year thing your BP mentioned. When I had a calling with a scouting element I remember training days coming up frequently. When I say training day I mean day. A big group would get together, drive 2 hours one way to the training location, watch training materials all day, then come home. Something to be aware of. If all you need is the youth protection training that might be a simple 30 minute video you can watch online. It’s been a while so I’m not up on the training requirements anymore.
As far as the “calling” itself, I hope you get to choose which merit badge you want to teach. If you don’t get to choose (e.g. we want you to be the environmental science MB counselor) then it has all the hallmarks of a calling.
If you get to choose, pick your passion. Be the coin collecting MB counselor, teach kids the basics of coin collecting, and help the kids complete the requirements to earn the badge.
Here’s a link to the various badges, each has a pdf with the requirements that the boys are expected to master.
http://www.scouting.org/meritbadges.aspxhttp://www.scouting.org/meritbadges.aspx” class=”bbcode_url”> Citizenship in the community might be a good fit? Bonus, it’s a badge that is required for eagle and all the boys hate doing it.
So time commitment.
1) Whenever a young man wants to take the merit badge you teach.
2) You may be asked to come in and teach all the boys your merit badge.
3) Every once in a while the church will run a MB clinic, a day set aside when many counselors are at church, the boys sign up for the classes they are interested in, and in one day they knock out a few MBs.
I think being a MB counselor is more like being a resource, meaning you are there for the scouts when there’s an interest in the MB you teach and when you are available. In other words just because you are a MB counselor I don’t think they would obligate you to attend a MB clinic or to teach your badge on mutual nights. I’d hope that they would work with your schedule.
April 25, 2016 at 11:17 am #311037Anonymous
GuestI suppose it could be a calling in the Corridor, wherever I have been it is not a calling. Most of the people who do it in my area are not members, they’re just people interested or experienced in the merit badge area. Like LH says, boys should contact you when they want to do your merit badge(s) or they may put on workshops on a Saturday or some troops regularly do merit badges as part of their weekly program. One must be registered with BSA and undergo background checks, etc., and follow two deep leadership rules (never be alone with a boy). (Nibbler and I were typing at the same time.)
April 25, 2016 at 4:14 pm #311038Anonymous
GuestGreat advice. Sounds non-doctrinal, and except for some training requirements, not onerous. I have a lot of skills in a lot of areas — music, business, swimming, just about any camping-related activity (was a canoe trip guide and outdoor enthusiast for decades), was a former guitar-builder/luthier for wood working, and many other areas. It sounds like I would need to define the boundaries, and it doesn’t sound like it has to be a calling either if I limit the areas in which I do the merit badge counseling. It sounds like my Bishop got the message I sent him about my boundaries and is working with me — a positive sign. The position is simply a modified scouting version of what I offered to do — be a supportive parent and put on an activity once a month is the YM leadership liked the idea.
Sounds like something I could consider…could give me some “membership” in the community without going back to the way I was three or four years ago.
I said I liked this Bishop, and this is one of the reasons why. He has pretty good judgment when he has the necessary background information. And he is not approaching this from the armchair of judgmentalism.
SD
April 25, 2016 at 4:38 pm #311039Anonymous
GuestSilentDawning wrote:…was a former guitar-builder/luthier for wood working…
I’ve got a guitar that has an action that is waaaaay too high… where do you live?
April 25, 2016 at 4:54 pm #311040Anonymous
Guestnibbler wrote:SilentDawning wrote:…was a former guitar-builder/luthier for wood working…
I’ve got a guitar that has an action that is waaaaay too high… where do you live?

I’ll send a PM…but I will say this — I’m a bass-only luthier. I only rarely worked on six-string guitars, usually under duress. The extent of my 6-string work was to build a body with a classy finish to fit a custom neck once, complete with a tremolo unit though. That was fun and apparently successful, particularly since the guy who hired me was a guitar repairman but didn’t do building work.
My latest project is a 6-string piccolo bass. Taking a body I like and putting a 6-string neck on it to replace it’s already rare 5-string neck.
April 25, 2016 at 6:36 pm #311041Anonymous
GuestI think it is a wonderful match for you right now. April 25, 2016 at 7:25 pm #311042Anonymous
GuestI think this is right down your alley as well. You seem to have quite a bit to offer as far as merit badges go – you might want to check with the Scoutmaster and see what areas they’d like to focus on and set your limits that way. However, for some more obscure merit badges it is sometimes tougher to find a counselor. April 25, 2016 at 7:28 pm #311043Anonymous
GuestOld-Timer wrote:I think it is a wonderful match for you right now.
I had written to him telling him I’d take on a monthly assignment, not a calling, to do an activity with the Young Men since my son is of that age. This was a pre-emptive email a week before I started going back to church.
He apparently never saw it and asked me to be a SS President and to head up a massive service project for the community. I refused that one as it didn’t respect anything I had suggested, and I wasn’t interested.
After he read the email I reforwarded he came out with this scouting proposal (as I will reframe it). So, he overlapped that with the scouting “needs” (if any). That is consistent with my conception of service and passion. Checkbox checked affirmative

I am pleased he hasn’t yet shared any comments I’ve heard before like “what about your temple covenants” or “that isn’t where I need you” or some other egocentric response. After I mentioned it, I sent an email asking to explore the idea, at which time I will find out what he thinks the position entails and set any minimal boundaries and expecations. I don’t want to be a PITA (Pain in the Assets) but I feel sick when I think of a calling that I have to be “released from” to stop doing if it doesn’t work for me anymore at some point.
Let’s see what happens.
The thing that bugs me is that the person who calls you to the position isn’t the one you report to. In which case, you really need a second boundary-setting meeting with that person — I suspect it’s the Scoutmaster you report to in this position — correct?
April 25, 2016 at 7:30 pm #311044Anonymous
GuestDarkJedi wrote:I think this is right down your alley as well. You seem to have quite a bit to offer as far as merit badges go – you might want to check with the Scoutmaster and see what areas they’d like to focus on and set your limits that way. However, for some more obscure merit badges it is sometimes tougher to find a counselor.
I wouldn’t mind trying to find someone with the right skills if there is a need. I can be quite resourceful that way and have a wide network right now. Thanks for the encouragement. I actually feel a tich of engagement with what he suggested, particularly since I would like to see my son do more than sit in front of Minecraft for 12 hours a day.
April 25, 2016 at 9:30 pm #311045Anonymous
GuestIf SilentDawning and Nibbler were ever to see eye to eye, wouldn’t there be a big risk of SilentDawning’s horn poke Nibbler’s 3rd eye? Just saying they need to be careful before they get too buddy buddy over strumming the gee tar. -
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.