Home Page Forums General Discussion A YW Career Night

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 32 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #211033
    Anonymous
    Guest

    There was a guest post on BCC about a YW that hosted a Career Night. Boy do I wish this was in my daughter’s YW group, but I really don’t think that’s going to happen. In our new ward, all they talk about is marriage and being a SAHM, and she just barely turned 14. She is turned off by this, especially since we had such kick-ass YW leaders in our ward before the boundary change, and of course I’ve never been a SAHM. Some good discussion on this post: https://bycommonconsent.com/2016/10/17/83259/

    #315348
    Anonymous
    Guest

    My sister – who was a journalist before she became a lawyer served as co-leader for activity days for the preteen girls. Her co-leader told the girls that they should get as much education as they can so that they can better teach their children/help them with home work and just in case your spouse dies suddenly.

    She was surprised that this is still taught in this day and age.

    We no longer teach that it is wrong for a woman to work outside the home as it is a financial necessity for so many of our members. However, for a woman to pursue a career voluntarily is something that we are very comfortable with. (I should add that there are some careers that we are much more comfortable with women having and others … not so much).

    #315349
    Anonymous
    Guest

    I’m old enough to have gotten the old-school full treatment in YW. And one of my few serious regrets in life is that I didn’t deliberately do better for my own girls. I let the still-predominant church culture message be the message they got. A lot of girls are going to look back, like the BCC commenter does, and say, “Why did I listen to them?”

    aspiringmormonwomen.org is a cool site. I vote for them to help overhaul the YW curriculum.

    #315350
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Ann wrote:

    I’m old enough to have gotten the old-school full treatment in YW. And one of my few serious regrets in life is that I didn’t deliberately do better for my own girls. I let the still-predominant church culture message be the message they got. A lot of girls are going to look back, like the BCC commenter does, and say, “Why did I listen to them?”

    aspiringmormonwomen.org is a cool site. I vote for them to help overhaul the YW curriculum.


    Don’t be too hard on yourself.

    Even as a guy I like Aspiring Mormon Women.

    #315351
    Anonymous
    Guest

    I like the idea of a career night. Is there any reason why we might not want to invite some men and women from the ward to talk about their career paths? I am just wondering if there is a reason why only women seem to be invited to speak. :?:

    #315352
    Anonymous
    Guest

    A YW career night that featured a school teacher, a hair dresser, and a paralegal. Huh. Talk about stereotypes.

    Those are all wonderful professions, but each woman admitted that she made a poor choice in that she focused on education as a “back up plan” instead of a primary plan. I find it interesting that they didn’t bring in a school principal, a movie set designer, and a litigator. They didn’t bring in women who were pleased with their level of education and accomplishments. They didn’t bring in women who were making 6 or 7 figure incomes.

    The people they brought in were women — who by their own admissions — had settled on education, degrees, and positions that were less than their full potential.

    Imagine if the YM had a career fair and they brought 3 poorly educated and under-employed men to talk to the YM. That wouldn’t happen.

    People learn from example. All the studies show that people will mimic what they know. If you want youth to accomplish great things, you show them inspirational examples. If you want to appear as if you are promoting careers for the YW, but you really want them to be SAHMs, you show them women who have not accomplished fame, financial independence, or reached the upper echelons of their professions.

    I knew someone who grew up poor but she had every opportunity for higher education. She chose to complete only an associates degree and married a poor provider. Years later, someone asked her why she had made such choices as she had her impoverished growing-up experience as a obvious lesson on what NOT to do. She reply, “It was all I knew. It was the pattern I was familiar with.”

    Let’s show our YW some positive and successful patterns of achievement. Let’s show them women who did not settle for a back-up plan type of profession or education.

    #315353
    Anonymous
    Guest

    One of the tragedies of my high school life was the future of my lab partner in a high school science class. She graduated as saluditorian (sp?) and then went into teaching elementary school children. Not that that’s a bad choice, but it was her father’s desire. She was a great mind and a light to me as we worked our way through the labs. A perfect analytical balance to my “Let’s push this through and get her done” approach. My understanding (and grades!) benifited much from her company, as did my need to visit with someone with different approaches to things. And thinking ahead of a future without such lights in the future workplace was sobering and discouraging. I wished that the mix of methods and personalities I had grown used to in my school career could continue in college and at work. Happily, this was in the early 70’s and things were starting to change. By the time I retired, thanks to the times and a company that participated in open policies, the public school mix I had hoped for was present at work. This is not to say I don’t appreciate the mom’s that want to stay at home, nor am not thankful to those that do, especially my wife who put things on hold to help stabilize and set the course for our children. I am very grateful for their sacrifices, and think that once the crises are over, they should have every opportunity continue their dreams.

    #315354
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Roy wrote:

    I like the idea of a career night. Is there any reason why we might not want to invite some men and women from the ward to talk about their career paths? I am just wondering if there is a reason why only women seem to be invited to speak. :?:

    I wonder if I explained myself well in this question. Suppose there is a man that works as a Veterinarian and lives in the ward. Would he be a good choice to do a presentation on his field to the YW? What are the pros and cons of inviting someone from the opposite gender of the audience?

    I guess I am just imagining that we as a church want to show the YW women that have chosen family friendly careers. Does that make sense? It has the feel of… this is what you can do in addition to being a mother. Am I off base here?

    #315355
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Roy:

    I find women have always managed to figure out ways to customize a balance of career and family. It is what women do.

    Too often, I see our YW pushed towards careers that are lower paying as a way to force them into a SAHM roll. A dear friend’s daughter wanted to go to medical school. The parents did all in their power to discourage their daughter. When they proudly told me that they had succeeded, I was stunned. That daughter could’ve worked 2 mornings a week as a physician and made more money than working 80 hours a week at minimum wage. The parents have forced her into a role of SAHM. She is financially trapped.

    The parents were concerned that if their daughter had the potential to make a significant income, she would be tempted to work. They did what they did out of “love”.

    I come across that attitude frequently. It makes me so sad.

    A healthier attitude would be to trust adult children to make excellent decisions for themselves and their families.

    #315356
    Anonymous
    Guest

    amateurparent wrote:

    Too often, I see our YW pushed towards careers that are lower paying as a way to force them into a SAHM roll. A dear friend’s daughter wanted to go to medical school. The parents did all in their power to discourage their daughter. When they proudly told me that they had succeeded, I was stunned. That daughter could’ve worked 2 mornings a week as a physician and made more money than working 80 hours a week at minimum wage. The parents have forced her into a role of SAHM. She is financially trapped.

    More to the point, this leaves a lot of women financially trapped in bad marriages because they have no means of supporting themselves and the children once they find out that the RM everybody else thinks can walk on water is a very different person behind closed doors.

    #315357
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Quote:

    NightSG wrote:

    “More to the point, this leaves a lot of women financially trapped in bad marriages because they have no means of supporting themselves and the children once they find out that the RM everybody else thinks can walk on water is a very different person behind closed doors.”

    Yes. It is horrific to me that women are too often put into a situation in which there is no easy escape. Lots of children. Poor education and job skills .. And an expectation that extended family and the LDS church will step in to support them financially as needed. Extended family and the church doesn’t expect to help out long term.

    The truth is that individual wards are not set up to finacially support divorced parents. In my limited experience, it looks like high earner single mothers seem to keep affiliation with the church. I see too many low earner divorced mothers feel marginalized by their religious communities due to their financial needs .. or they quickly re-marry for financial reasons without full regard for anything else in the relatioship other than financial need.

    #315358
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Here’s why LDS Trump supporters scare the crap out of me. There is a strong correlation between Trump supporters and hostile sexism. While many Mormons are ‘old-fashioned’ benevolent sexists, putting women on a pedestal, there are also plenty of hostile sexists, too. Those are the ones who have strong feelings of resentment toward women, groups like men’s rights activists. I wish I could say I’ve never met a Mormon like this, but I have even heard a youth speaker say in a talk over the pulpit that the boys in Steubenville had their bright futures ruined by girls’ accusations. True story. That’s what hostile sexism looks like.

    http://www.vox.com/2016/11/1/13480416/trump-supporters-sexism

    #315359
    Anonymous
    Guest

    hawkgrrrl wrote:

    There is a strong correlation between Trump supporters and hostile sexism.

    There’s a much stronger correlation between margarine consumption and divorces in Maine. Why aren’t you as concerned about the sanctity of marriage in the northeast?

    [img]http://tylervigen.com/chart-pngs/4.png[/img]

    #315360
    Anonymous
    Guest

    And now back to our regularly scheduled programming….

    The discussion is about YW career night and career options.

    FWIW, one of the counselors in our stake RSP is a single professional woman in her 30s, and we previously had a divorced single mother, also a professional, in that position. The former was released to be YWP in her ward. One of the counselors in the stake Primary presidency is also a single (divorced, childless) professional woman.

    #315361
    Anonymous
    Guest

    DarkJedi wrote:

    And now back to our regularly scheduled programming….


    NightSG – stop trying to “butter” us up. 😆 😆 😆

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 32 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.