Home Page › Forums › General Discussion › Happiness and Suffering
- This topic is empty.
-
AuthorPosts
-
March 4, 2017 at 4:52 pm #211213
Anonymous
GuestSome of you have noticed that I have refocused my life on achieving happiness. I have been watching harvard studies on Youtube, Ted Talks, reading about it. I have to confess, that putting my personal happiness at the forefront has done much to make me happy. I am not talking about selfish happiness — where I reject doing things that require discipline, sacrifice, etcetera. There is a lot of service in my life (as much as when I was in Bpric, HPGL, Stake Exec Sec). And yes, that makes me happy.
But then I read stories about Job and how he suffered for God to the max. It has me seriously questioning whether aspects of the Mormon lifestyle that require what I feel is SUFFERING SACRIFICE day in and day out, is truly a recipe for happiness. We have the promise that sacrifice now will increase happiness in the next life, but that is so far off, and the promises are not guaranteed. So, I don’t feel willing to give up my discretionary income, my spare time in driving across town to set up chairs, to help people move (with the back problems it has created over the years), to chase less active people, thus challenging my testimony.
I would like to hear comments on the relationship between sacrifice and happiness. To me, there is good sacrifice — sacrifice which makes you happy due to the results it achieves in this life (and this includes blessing the lives of others). Sacrifice that aligns with your passions and talents, and doesn’t have you doing things you detest regularly. Bad sacrifice really hurts and doesn’t seem to generate the necessary results to make it worthwhile.
Is there such a thing as good sacrifice and bad sacrifice, with the test being the extent to which it makes you happy — the object and design of our existence?
March 4, 2017 at 8:16 pm #317581Anonymous
GuestSome of the best advice I ever heard was when my spouse was extended a stake calling and the counselor said to him, “Be careful not to sacrifice your family on the alter of service.” This is what my parents have chosen to do and as a result their relationships with their children and grandchildren have really suffered. I feel bad for them because they feel they that in giving their life in the service of the church they really will be blessed. But as for right now, they have lost much more than I think they will ever gain.
March 4, 2017 at 11:12 pm #317582Anonymous
GuestSilentDawning wrote:I would like to hear comments on the relationship between sacrifice and happiness.
As with many things I believe there’s a balance to be struck here as well. In the spirit of “whosoever will lose his life for my sake shall find it” I tried putting everyone else’s needs ahead of my own, I took it to an extreme. Ultimately it didn’t work out. I was unhappy and I started to crack… which can interfere with your ability to serve. Then there’s the opposite extreme. Never putting someone else’s needs ahead of your own. So IMO there’s a balance. A balance where you’ll probably always feel unsure whether you’re being lazy or you’re giving too much.
It’s easier to sacrifice when the
purposeof the sacrifice is obvious. Helping someone move, a sacrifice; the purpose, it gets someone’s stuff from point A to point B, at the very least it saves someone some $green on hiring movers. When you’re done it’s obvious you accomplished something. Some programs at church feel like they don’t have a true purpose, it’s more busy work. There are a lot of programs at church that do accomplish things but where they “get” you is in the volume. I think we’ve created a culture where there’s an expectation to participate in every. single. program. that comes along and there are simply too many. The programs are nice… but as a culture we kinda feel guilted into doing them all until it has reached a point where there’s an expectation that everyone participate in all the programs. Boundaries erode and we fall into the more is better trap.
SilentDawning wrote:We have the promise that sacrifice now will increase happiness in the next life, but that is so far off, and the promises are not guaranteed.
I’ll work on being happy in this life and I’ll work on being happy in the afterlife when I’m in the afterlife. Seems simple, straight forward. Besides, being happy helps us be of better service to people.
SilentDawning wrote:the object and design of our existence?
As I get older and as I have taken upon myself more and more responsibilities I’d say that that the only object and design of our existence is the ones we make for ourselves.
Never forget:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2nuSnE6GNdohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2nuSnE6GNdo” class=”bbcode_url”>
March 5, 2017 at 12:54 am #317583Anonymous
GuestSacrifice is beneficial, except when it isn’t. It aids happiness, except when it doesn’t. The line is different for each person.
March 5, 2017 at 5:25 am #317584Anonymous
GuestI think there are “good” sacrifices and “bad” sacrifices. I agree with Ray that it might be different for different people, but there are some instances in the scriptures where what is acceptable and not acceptable is brought out. I just undertook a study of Isaiah (don’t ask me why, I may be crazy, but it just may be a lunatic you’re looking for… :crazy: ) and chapter 1 talks about the Lord not wanting our sacrifices, that He’s had enough of them and it’s time to learn to do good and rescue the oppressed, etc.To me a “good” sacrifice is one that makes me feel good and that I want to do because I want do it, not because I have been “commanded” to do it or because it is my “(priesthood) duty.” In that process it is very likely that such a sacrifice helped someone else. Conversely, a “bad” sacrifice is one I am doing not because I want to, that I do begrudgingly, and that I see no benefit in for me or others. I have seen in my own ward those who have sacrificed their families for church service and the results are not pretty. I will not do that, nor will I sacrifice my own well being or sanity.
March 5, 2017 at 6:40 pm #317585Anonymous
GuestSince I read your post initially, I have had the same thought for 2 days. Happiness is personal. I know people who are sublimely happy in the LDS church. In fact they feel unhappy when they aren’t connected to it. Whether it’s the ritual, the culture, the faith, it means everything to them.
On the flip side just the opposite.
What makes one person happy makes another unhappy. Even when we go through things simultaneously.
Even here on this board we have variances in happiness and suffering.
It’s a great question, but I find no pat answer to it. It’s as individual as our fingerprints.
March 6, 2017 at 4:51 pm #317586Anonymous
GuestFinancially I am an ant. I am happiest sacrificing daily perks and frills for the sake of financial security. I have felt superior to the financial grasshoppers that seem to not have any sense of discipline. And truly, not having enough money to cover one’s needs at the end of the month is a recipe for unhappiness.
However, I have come to realize that there is value in being able to part with some money in order to gain experiences. I have also come to realize that in slowly amassing my little treasure trove I am merely following my nature as an “ant”. That makes it seem like not much of a sacrifice at all – and certainly not superior to a financial grasshopper that is similarly following their internal programming.
My spouse helps me to moderate. She makes compromises with my frugal nature most days also helps me to understand when parting with some money can be more important in the bigger picture.
In summary, I do believe that there are some big picture happiness ingredients that apply to all (hierarchy of needs) yet in the details there can be more than one way to arrive at the destination. I also believe that the sweet spot tends to exist somewhere in the middle and not on the extreme edges.
March 7, 2017 at 3:09 pm #317587Anonymous
GuestStayforthedip wrote:Some of the best advice I ever heard was when my spouse was extended a stake calling and the counselor said to him, “Be careful not to sacrifice your family on the alter of service.”
This is what my parents have chosen to do and as a result their relationships with their children and grandchildren have really suffered. I feel bad for them because they feel they that in giving their life in the service of the church they really will be blessed. But as for right now, they have lost much more than I think they will ever gain.
So very true. What gets me about a lot of service/missionary work lessons is that we always talk about doing it outside the home, with strangers, home teaching, etc. etc. Very rarely does the instructor or members of the class bring up that the most important service and missionary work we can do is in our own home with our spouse and children. I personally know of some men in the church who do their home teaching, go set up chairs, hold a calling, but are horrible when it comes to helping their wife in the home. A lot of members don’t get this and think they have to have a challenging calling or do 100% home teaching to feel fulfilled and put God first. I believe by putting my family first and serving them, I’m putting God first since the family is the fundamental unit of His plan and church.
March 8, 2017 at 5:11 pm #317588Anonymous
GuestUberDan wrote:I believe by putting my family first and serving them, I’m putting God first since the family is the fundamental unit of His plan and church.
I believe that it’s what is going to make us the happiest. That is what is most important. I know that in old age, having close family ties is important for longevity and health, so I believe in putting family at or near the top.
But I have tried to put my family first in my time in the past, and they can never agree to do anything as a unit. I guess I have given up on that. I then would do things separately (father, daughter, or Father, son), but then onlookers tells us our family is dysfunctional. I kept doing the duet stuff anyway, as it worked in at least creating a good relationship that way.
I do think that sacrificing too much for callings, is bad suffering. I have almost zero to do with any of the people I home taught, with who served along side me in my High Priest Group days, or in the church throughout my life. It turns over in our Ward so that all the existing leaders are new people.
But family — they are yours for the long haul and yes, should come first.
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.