- This topic is empty.
-
AuthorPosts
-
August 13, 2017 at 9:09 pm #211302
Anonymous
GuestThis morning when I sat down in Sacrament Meeting with my husband, I told myself (and him) that I was not going to be negative today about anything that I heard in church. I was going to look for the positive and try to get something worthwhile out of the two hours I was going to attend (Sacrament Meeting and Relief Society). It seems like every Sunday is a repeat of the last. I start out bored. After all, I’m coming up on my 69th birthday and have heard it all before, so many times I can hardly force myself to sit through it again. Then, one of the speakers or teachers says something that offends me. It’s usually some self-righteous comment, and I end up missing everything else that’s said for focusing on one remark. Before the meetings are over, I’m feeling so alone, like I don’t have a soulmate in this entire 15 million+ member Church. By the time I get home, I’m generally in tears. Today, one of the speakers in Sacrament Meeting told about an experience he’d had recently, when he’d stopped by someone’s house after church to return something to the family. They mentioned that they’d gone to a different ward that morning, to a missionary farewell, and had stopped on the way home for dinner at Marie Callender’s. Apparently it had really upset him that someone would do such a thing, and he compared eating out on Sunday to the story of Esau selling his birthright for a mess of pottage. He spent enough time on his analogy and on judging this family for “just missing the whole point” (of what, he didn’t come right out and say) that my husband told me afterward, he could just sense how annoyed I was. I realize it wasn’t all that huge of a deal, but it just struck me as so holier-than-thou that it completely changed how I’ll see this man in the future. When it comes to “missing the whole point,” I wonder how he figured that being judgmental fits in.
Then, in Relief Society, the lesson was on The Book of Mormon. The teacher asked us to share experiences we’d had in giving copies of The Book of Mormon to non-members. One woman told about giving a copy to a young woman in her early teens. She said she wasn’t sure what religion this young woman was, but that, based on her ethnicity, she thought she was probably “either a Hindu or one of those other idol-worshiping religions.”
I’m sorry, that whole rant was probably unnecessary, and maybe I’m being as judgmental as either of the two people I gave as examples. I just wish I could feel that I belong. I don’t seem to fit into the Mormon culture at all (or maybe it’s the Utah Mormon culture; I don’t know). Anyway, any comments would be appreciated, and if I have just over-reacted, you can tell me that, too. It probably won’t make me feel any worse than I already do. Somehow, though, I feel as if, among this particular group of people, I’ll find someone who would have felt the same way I did.
August 13, 2017 at 9:55 pm #318805Anonymous
GuestI think you’ll find several that feel like you. I have exactly the same struggles and half said to myself more than once “I’m going to positive today” only to get irritated at the first speaker and it’s all downhill from there. FWIW, SM was good in my ward today, very Christ and scripture centered and a noticeable uptick over the past few weeks, and I came home in a good mood. I don’t have anything new to share. When it gets bad out comes my tablet and I start reading scriptures or a talk I do like or doing my own research on the topic at hand or another (if the topic is preparedness or family history for example). Other than that I try extra hard to be nice to people, speaking to people I don’t normally speak to and so forth.
I’d love to say it gets better, but for me it hasn’t gotten appreciably better. How I cope with it has improved though.
August 13, 2017 at 10:26 pm #318806Anonymous
GuestRemember that God loves all of his sheep. Even the black sheep. It’s okay to be a black sheep. It’s how God created you and he did it for a reason. Maybe it’s to give the flock some perspective. Maybe it’s to touch lives that couldn’t be touched by a white sheep. Maybe it’s something else. I think a lot of them white sheep have these preconceived notions that all sheep are supposed to be white, so they attack the off-color sheep with bleach and try to fix them.
Paraphrasing Elder Anderson in his visit to my mission, “A lot of different kinds of people can have testimonies and be good members of the church.” That statement could not be more true.
August 13, 2017 at 11:01 pm #318807Anonymous
GuestI’ll feel with you today Katzpur. I really struggle in this area. My struggle is that I often can’t tell how much of the “problem” is with me and how much is with the situation. What I mean by that is that I wonder whether the issue is me focusing on the negatives or whether the overall experience itself is mostly a bad experience. Could I change my state of mind to focus on positive things or is it easier to change my environment to a more positive one?
I haven’t shared this story here because I really do try to focus on the positives. More on that later but first the story.
About a year ago I went to the temple to help with baptisms. I was going to be one of baptism witnesses. Issue one: my temple clothes didn’t fit me anymore, I put on a
lotof weight, 😳 so I needed clothes when I got there. At the temple they gave me a white jumpsuit to wear… just like every other time. Shortly after sitting in the witness chair someone running the baptistry approached me, found out that I would only be performing the duties of a witness (not baptizing), and made me change into a white shirt and white pants because witnesses couldn’t wear the white jumpsuit.I don’t know if there has been a rule change at temples but it didn’t sound right to me. There have been
plentyof instances where a witness will wear the white jumpsuit and then take over baptizing duty at the midpoint of the evening, so I know it could be done, I’ve done it countless times… but if it will make this guy happy, whatever. I change. When I get back that same guy has some other issue with my appearance and makes me go back and change again. I can’t remember what it was the second time but I remember that at that stage, the dance the guy was putting me through was starting to get annoying. I went with one of my kids and the youth were instructed to bring a family name so they could do ordinance work for them. We attempted to do this but found that someone in some other state had “stolen” (did the ordinance work without permission from anyone in my family) every single one of the family names that we had prepared. Once you put the info out there it’s out of your control I guess.
Our kid couldn’t do any baptisms for anyone in our family, they had already been done. Well the leaders had made a huge deal out of every kid bringing a name so our kid got in “trouble” for not bringing one and I found myself having to explain our situation (give an excuse) to no fewer than three different PH leaders. Just like the TPS reports in Office Space.
From the Pharisee measuring my inseam and trying to spot any flaw that he could to make sure I measured up to whatever handbook he was going off of to the system that completely misses the point of turning the hearts of the children to their fathers by robbing my kid of all opportunities to do ordinances for our family… it wasn’t a good day. I wasn’t even mad or sad, the predominant thought was, “this is stupid.”
So why this story? Ray, if you’re reading this I really don’t mean to pick on you but here goes…
When we talk about the good things that happen at church, like Ray’s story about the temple president that welcomed in the casually dressed couple with open arms… well, I haven’t had those experiences. Most temple experiences are forgettable (it’s the temple, they’re mostly all the same) but if one visit stands out more than others in recent years it’s the story I shared above.
I typically don’t bring those stories here because, to be honest, it can be invalidating when positive stories are shared, maybe in an effort to counterbalance by saying, “not all the church is that way, look at this positive thing.” I don’t know, I’m just talking, but it does put me in the position where I feel like I’m the negative standout of the thread… even when I think most would legitimately struggle to find something positive had they experienced what I had experienced.
Sorry, I don’t mean to step on any toes or reprimand. Just saying that being honest in relating
myexperiences can be a very difficult thing to do. No one wants to be the negative guy. No one wants to feel like their bad experiences are being superseded by good things that happen elsewhere. Katzpur, sorry for hijacking.
August 13, 2017 at 11:28 pm #318808Anonymous
GuestMore on topic 😳 A portion of one talk during SM focused on getting burned out in doing church stuff and the people that experience burnout were compared to the 5 virgins that didn’t have enough oil. They burnt out. Get it? Rough. Especially since I think that the people that experience the most burnout in church are the very ones that are keeping the boat afloat.
August 14, 2017 at 12:24 am #318809Anonymous
GuestI’ve found that every ward has those people, with some pretty bizzare beliefs in the other direction. Those who are vehemently opposed to interracial marriages, for example. No one dares speak up against them without making a scene, and a few other bizzaros might actually agree with them. We’ve got a Church largely founded upon the premise, “If it feels right, it is right.” With the diversity of people and experiences, you’re bound to get some nonsensical beliefs. Trust me, others were biting their tongues as well. Speaking of those accused of idol-woshiping, I went to a Buddhist Temple for Sunday service this morning. I really enjoyed it. The main emphasis of the lecture today, was on how all the universe and everything in it is interconnected. Just like we don’t look at the human body, and see “this is one cell, and this is a different cell”, there isn’t really a you and me. We’re all part of the same “body”. When we impart kindness to another, we are showing kindness to ourselves in turn. When one of us suffers, we all suffer together. The more we learn of another person, the more we love them; because they’re really not all that different from us. And above all, I hope you know, you are not alone. We’re all in this together.
August 14, 2017 at 1:12 pm #318810Anonymous
GuestKatzpur – you are not alone. My “day” job can be stressful, but it is up and down. Sundays are consistently one of the hardest days of the week as of late. Most of my ward is quite good, but I just have soooo many times I want to raise my hand and correct or give a different opinion. But we know how that will go. I keep going to keep the peace with my wife, but I do think at some point I am going to have to back off a bit. I think it keeps me from “healing”. During the week I can generally say I am not angry or upset about Mormonism, but if there is a day I realize I am not stage 5 it will be a Sunday.
August 14, 2017 at 2:44 pm #318811Anonymous
GuestKatzpur wrote:
I’m sorry, that whole rant was probably unnecessary, and maybe I’m being as judgmental as either of the two people I gave as examples. I just wish I could feel that I belong. I don’t seem to fit into the Mormon culture at all (or maybe it’s the Utah Mormon culture; I don’t know). Anyway, any comments would be appreciated, and if I have just over-reacted, you can tell me that, too. It probably won’t make me feel any worse than I already do. Somehow, though, I feel as if, among this particular group of people, I’ll find someone who would have felt the same way I did.
You are absolutely not alone, and I think you would be surprised how many in your own ward even feel the same way as you. I think its easy to think that were alone, but I think thats largely because we don’t dare talk to others and find other like minded people among us. This is largely due to culture, but it also keeps us safe because it can make life an absolute mess for us (shunning and gossip or unwanted meetings) if we disclose too much to the wrong people and it gets around. And that is why I have stayed silent and suffered alone all these years. Sometimes I wish I knew others who think and feel like me though… it would be so great to sit down with someone who understands and relates.
Sunday school is the worst for me. Some of the comments really strike nerves with me, or I get bored, or tired of some of the rationalizations and half-truths. Just this Sunday I took a small notepad with me and drew in it, and it really helped. I don’t know why I havent tried that sooner. I find that when I start feeling that way that I tend to want to fidget a bit, and drawing gave me that permission to “fidget” (or scribble out my frustration) while still looking like I was paying attention. I thought I would mention it in case you want to give it a try and see if it helps you in those moments.
I came across a blog post not too long ago that you may really enjoy – I think it relates:
https://faithfulexpansions.wordpress.com/2017/08/06/the-pain-of-the-sister-in-the-pew-next-to-you/ August 14, 2017 at 4:07 pm #318812Anonymous
GuestDarkJedi wrote:
I think you’ll find several that feel like you. I have exactly the same struggles and half said to myself more than once “I’m going to positive today” only to get irritated at the first speaker and it’s all downhill from there.
Yup. It’s like once the first irritating thing happens, my mood just changes and I have the hardest time even focusing on the rest of the meeting. Most of the time, the only time I really feel spiritually in tune and at peace is during the sacrament. (For a few weeks, even that changed when one of the members of the high priests group leadership decided that we needed some kind of policing to make sure nobody took the sacrament with the “wrong” hand, thereby showing the ultimate disrespect to God. Fortunately, that blew over fairly quickly.)August 14, 2017 at 4:18 pm #318813Anonymous
GuestBeefster wrote:
Remember that God loves all of his sheep. Even the black sheep. It’s okay to be a black sheep. It’s how God created you and he did it for a reason. Maybe it’s to give the flock some perspective. Maybe it’s to touch lives that couldn’t be touched by a white sheep.
I like that. It reminds me of “A Skeptic’s Prayer” by Margaret Rampton Munk:A SKEPTIC’S PRAYER
Is it true
Thou lovest best
Thy meek, unasking children?
Thou has made us
So diverse, so various,
Yet in the image of a Sire
Who filled the universe
With His creative fire.
What father has supposed
His child would grow to manhood
Only hearing and affirming?
What man could honor such a son?
How could a mind that,
Like a sponge,
Absorbs but never questions,
Doubts,
Or wonders why
Be offspring and apprentice
To a God?
It may be, Lord,
Thou canst never love me
With the calm relief
a father feels
For his obedient child–
The one who’s never any trouble.
But use me
As a bridge
To those more wayward still
Than I.
I cannot give them all the answers;
But they will not ask
The ones who think they can.
Let me speak
To Thy lost sheep
As one who,
Understanding how they went astray,
Still loves the Shepherd.
August 14, 2017 at 5:50 pm #318814Anonymous
GuestI think all of us (or most of us) can identify with those frustrated feelings…and especially how exhausting it gets when it goes on week after week like that. For me…it is always a thing i review and reflect and meditate on…because I know another week like it is coming…so what can be done?
The good thing I heard was that you were honestly giving it a good effort…starting the approach positively…
Katzpur wrote:
I told myself (and him) that I was not going to be negative today about anything that I heard in church
So…if nothing else…thumbs up
:thumbup: for you that you gave it an effort. Even if it didn’t last.Nibbler makes a good point that while these feelings are real, and others try to keep it positive…it doesn’t help to just be told “you get out of it what you put into it, my day was wonderful because I chose to be happy.” that kind of response just isn’t so realistic, I don’t think. Not helpful much, anyway.
Truth is…so much of church is dealing with these feelings and trying to find ways to make it meaningful and worthwhile…and sometimes we do find a gem here and there and it can remind us it is worth continuing to try. But sometimes those gems are few and far between…and it becomes painful to endure week after week.
I just think going to church is our practice ground where we can reflect on why things bother us, why it is boring, what we have tried and didn’t get resutls…what we can continue to try.
I guess it just comes down to looking ahead with hope and faith that we are smart enough to learn from our experiences…and choose what to do next time.
Maybe others have some ideas of things they do…I’ve heard some. Looking ahead…things you could try:
1) Bring a tablet or book, like DJ…and use it when you need to tune out stuff that makes you negative
2) Find others in the ward that may feel the same way or just others you want to conenct to and talk in the hallways and replace the negative witha positive connection of some kind
3) Skip church more often
This past week…I chose #3 again. I found no negativity on my sabbath.
August 14, 2017 at 7:08 pm #318815Anonymous
GuestKatzpur wrote:
It reminds me of “A Skeptic’s Prayer” by Margaret Rampton Munk:A SKEPTIC’S PRAYER
[snip]
Man, that’s an awesome poem. I need to get me a plaque of that and hang it on my wall!
August 14, 2017 at 7:32 pm #318816Anonymous
GuestHeber13 wrote:3) Skip church more often
This past week…I chose #3 again. I found no negativity on my sabbath.
😆 I can honestly say the same. I worked really hard on Saturday to get stuff done because my husband was sick. Sunday morning, he can’t go, and I am feeling really anxious about corralling 2 girls at church (and just in general), so we all stayed home. I got a good long nap in when the baby was sleeping, and then just played with my daughters while my husband recovered.
I took the 2 girls to visit their adopted grandma (and my VT companion), and we had a good long visit. She loved having the kids in her house, and I loved the chance to keep an easier eye on the baby in company.
August 14, 2017 at 8:29 pm #318817Anonymous
GuestI deal with it by getting my spiritual jollies outside the church — in my relationships with non-members, community service, other groups I hob nob with. All outside the church. So, the church footprint gets much smaller and less annoying. The shoe is so much smaller than it used to be that the pebbles in the shoe are like grains of sand. I’ve made my own fun somewhere else. But i still go to LDS church. I also get a kick out of making people think. Read my story about the blue shirt in the Active topics area, hopefully. I do that a lot. It’s not offensive, but it makes people think. For example, when I’m in a meeting and if someone called the Hindus one of those other idol worshipping religions, I’d try to say something that makes people think. Perhaps by asking how we can we combat the notion among Hindus that we worship men rather than idols, as evidenced by our hymn “Praise to the Man”? I’ve had investigators drop the missionaries over that hymn being sung at church. Ask the question and open it for discussion.
I also take every opportunity I can to teach people not be judgmental. Had a lesson where I showed up in a flowered shirt, jeans, and Van sneakers in High Priests. Taught the lesson on judgmentalism and then someone said “I could be judgmental about the way you are dressed for church today” and asked everyone “What did you think when you walked into this room and saw me dressed this way??”
Powerful teaching moment as no one wanted to share the judgmentalism I know they all felt. Deer in the headlights. Caught. Busted. When I indicated I had permission to be dressed that way as an object lesson the room erupted into smiles and appreciation for the power of the lesson.
Stuff like that. Rock the boat without sinking the ship. It’s very therapeutic.
August 14, 2017 at 9:36 pm #318818Anonymous
GuestI deal with it by having a couple of specific responses. I open the hymn book and enjoy worshipful messages, or I take the overall topic and compose my own talks on the topic. Simply vowing to “gut it out and be positive” won’t work. It is a form of suppression, and suppression is not healthy. Substituting something positive works much better.
nibbler, I wish I could say I was shocked by your temple example, but I’m not. It was wrong to make you change from the jumpsuit. There is no policy that dictates witnesses be dressed one particular way. It was a mistake, compounded by more mistakes. It sucks, and I am sorry it’s happened to you. Please don’t suppress those stories simply to try to be positive. Reading and supporting is what we try to do.
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.