- This topic is empty.
-
Posts
-
Actually some parts of it are very EASY to live. A lot of people take drugs and smoke, but a lot don’t. If you don’t already, you don’t need to get into that side of things.
The three drinks might be a bit harder, but it’s worth mentioning if you’re not taking heroin or crack cocaine, you’re already living part of the Word of Wisdom.
Brown wrote:I agree that there are definitely health advantages to not becoming addicted to tobacco or alcohol. But there are also health benefits to an occasional glass of red wine. Someone who has a drink at dinner once in a while is not going to knock 5 years off their life.
Coffee, I don’t think should dictate worthiness, but it is addictive. Caffiene addiction comes in many forms and currently I am trying to quit Mtn. Dew.
Also, excessive consumption of meat has been shown to cause heart disease and colon cancer. So I am not sure it is any better for you than alcohol or tobacco.
The key here is excessive. However, the WoW, does say “sparingly” I believe. And it encourages eating fiber (in the form of cereals) as well.
Most Americans eat meat for 2 meals a day. I would consider that excessive, wouldn’t you? Certainly not “sparingly”. Anyway, it is interesting that this got revived. Just tonight I was at a work event that served free beverages of all types. I told myself I didn’t care about the WoW because I don’t think it really bans coffee and alcohol. And yet when the drink servers came around, I just grabbed the water. Don’t really know what that means, but it just didn’t seem like there was any point in it even if I don’t think it is sinful.
It’s OK to not to drink alcohol, even if you no longer see it as supernaturally sinful or unhealthy in moderation. It is still a valid choice not to partake. If you don’t want to or it isn’t appealing, then don’t. Brown wrote:Most Americans eat meat for 2 meals a day. I would consider that excessive, wouldn’t you? Certainly not “sparingly”.
I think it depends how much there is, and how much in the way of greens is getting eaten as well. Processed meat is a lot worse for you than simple joints etc.
In this particular context, I wouldn’t include chicken and fish in the same bracket as red meat either. Red meat’s great for protein, but high in fat… venison is probably the exception here.
Quote:the weakest need the literal law
This is pretty universally true I suppose and would be interesting for the church to consider overall. However, the rub is that the weakest don’t consider themselves weak. Even the majority of budding alcoholics think they are social drinkers. I think a new WOW should be written that prohibits the use of cream of mushroom soup in casseroles. If you can’t make a simple white sauce, you have no business in the kitchen.
I’m with Brown, though. Even if I don’t think the WoW is as big a deal as it is portrayed, I always just drink a water or Diet Coke. I don’t see the point to drinking alcohol or coffee; neither is vital, and both are so expensive (and in the case of alcohol, all those empty calories)! I certainly don’t judge others who do differently, though.
SamBee wrote:Brown wrote:Most Americans eat meat for 2 meals a day. I would consider that excessive, wouldn’t you? Certainly not “sparingly”.
I think it depends how much there is, and how much in the way of greens is getting eaten as well. Processed meat is a lot worse for you than simple joints etc.
In this particular context, I wouldn’t include chicken and fish in the same bracket as red meat either. Red meat’s great for protein, but high in fat… venison is probably the exception here.
Well we can sit and debate what is meat and what is “sparingly”, but the point that bothers me is that it is just completely ignored in the TR interview, whereas one sip of alcohol and you are SOL. It just seems like a strange double standard. I have never been asked if make grains the staff of my life, but I always get asked about coffee and tobacco. Is an occasional glass of wine worse than an occasional 24oz ribeye? Many of us eat very poorly. I know I do. But I can eat whoppers for every meal and be living the “code of health” as long as I skip that cup of joe.
As is often the case in the church, the rule and the scriptural justification for the rule are not necessarily the same thing. The WoW as implemented as a litmus test for temple attendance, and section 89 of the Doctrine and Covenants are certainly related, but more like distant cousins. While originally it may have been all about personal health, it now seems to be more about obedience and promoting a sense of being different from the rest of the world. Though the church may continue to co-opt language of ‘the Lord’s law of health’ etc, it’s really about obedience. The church owns the temples and makes the rules for temple attendance, and the rules can and do change from time to time. Whether the rules match the original intent of whatever it is that the rule is based on is irrelevant. I think it helps to make that distinction. While we’re on the topic, I might as well make a plug for the blog of a relative of a friend:
thesparitarian.blogspot.comBrown wrote:SamBee wrote:Brown wrote:Most Americans eat meat for 2 meals a day. I would consider that excessive, wouldn’t you? Certainly not “sparingly”.
I think it depends how much there is, and how much in the way of greens is getting eaten as well. Processed meat is a lot worse for you than simple joints etc.
In this particular context, I wouldn’t include chicken and fish in the same bracket as red meat either. Red meat’s great for protein, but high in fat… venison is probably the exception here.
Well we can sit and debate what is meat and what is “sparingly”, but the point that bothers me is that it is just completely ignored in the TR interview, whereas one sip of alcohol and you are SOL. It just seems like a strange double standard. I have never been asked if make grains the staff of my life, but I always get asked about coffee and tobacco. Is an occasional glass of wine worse than an occasional 24oz ribeye? Many of us eat very poorly. I know I do. But I can eat whoppers for every meal and be living the “code of health” as long as I skip that cup of joe.
I agree with you. I actually get very annoyed at the spreads in some of our leaving do’s etc. Lots of starch and cakes. Thankfully some people DO bring fruit, like grapes, and veg such as broccoli and carrots for dips.
Interestingly, the following published on my personal blog today – totally independent of this thread being revived. (Sometimes, the timing of stuff like this is almost eerie.) “My Simplistic, Summary Explanation of the Word of Wisdom”( http://thingsofmysoul.blogspot.com/2011/08/my-simplistic-summary-explanation-of.html
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.