Home Page Forums History and Doctrine Discussions Myth vs Literal Historical Account

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 3 posts - 31 through 33 (of 33 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #282507
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Orson wrote:

    It fascinates me how we can often take the lessons taught by a Spock or Yoda, because we know they are a 10, more easily than someone that is presented as a 1 because we doubt the validity of their historicity.

    Yes, that why they exist. In a way both figures are reminiscent of the old pagan gods of Rome (and elsewhere), who represented certain qualities, rather than a general figure like HF.

    Spock is a god of logic, self-control, science and war.

    Yoda is a god of mysticism, the elderly, nature and the warrior.

    Spock get resurrected too, remember.

    #282508
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Exactly, Orson.

    Just because some people (even most people in a particular culture) view someone historically as a real person and I don’t (say, Abraham, Job, Noah, Enoch, Jonah, etc., much less the figures in the Book of Mormon) doesn’t invalidate great lessons or teachings from their stories.

    If I can use Bill’s and Ted’s classic, “Be excellent to each other,” as the basis for a talk about charity, why in the world should I hesitate to use Moroni’s wonderful discourse in Moroni 7 about not calling good evil or evil good – especially if I use those verses to make the exact same point as I did when I quoted obviously fictional movie characters? As I’ve said in other threads, I still am open to the idea that the Book of Mormon account is historical (and I use that frame of reference when I talk about it at church, knowing most people there see it that way, even if my view of that possibility is much more complicated than theirs), but, regardless of how I view it, the lessons and messages in it don’t change either way.

    #282509
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Whoa. Funny how I never made that connection before. Mind minorly blown. Thanks, Orson and Ray.

Viewing 3 posts - 31 through 33 (of 33 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.